Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

OK, I'm not a big Green Day fan, but Dookie holds a soft spot in my heart for setting the bar that all poppy punk-n-roll bands should aspire to (and almost always miss).  

That said, this new tune is utter garbage.  It sounds like Maroon 5 tried to knock off Jack White.  This makes it the trifecta of suck.  Fall Out Boy is apoplectic yet feeling superior.

Don't blame me if you click:

 

 

Sounds straight out of 2004. Like the Vines and the Darkness had a stupid kid. Gross. 

  • Author

It doesn't even remotely sound like anything they've ever done.  It certainly doesn't sound like Billie Joe Armstrong on vocals.  I highly doubt one of the other guys sang it, but crimony, it's just flat out awful either way.

Yeah, that's pretty awful.

I enjoyed them a lot when I was younger.  I got super into The Who shortly after I got out of my pop punk/punk phase, and that was right when American Idiot was coming out.  It seemed like a great homage, and the perfect soundtrack to everything at the time.  I think that was my sophomore year at ISU.

I listened to it last year for the first time in over 10 years and chuckled at the idea of thinking this was even above average, let alone brilliant.

Dookie and Nimrod still hold up for what they are.

Edited by Al_4_ISU

  • Author

I never equated American Idiot to anything by The Who, but rather just a watered down version of their previously snottier selves.  That said, it was a whole lot better than this crap.

I fucking hate Green Day. I had a roommate in college who had their very first CD around ‘92, so I had to listen to that shit for years before they went mainstream.

That said, this is their best song.

I never equated American Idiot to anything by The Who, but rather just a watered down version of their previously snottier selves.  That said, it was a whole lot better than this crap.


It was the whole “rock opera” billing.
It doesn't even remotely sound like anything they've ever done.  It certainly doesn't sound like Billie Joe Armstrong on vocals.  I highly doubt one of the other guys sang it, but crimony, it's just flat out awful either way.


I agree with statements one and two but not three.

They created something different (for them). Sounds like rock n roll to me.

Billy Joe is the least interesting dude from... whatever group of dudes you might place him in from that type/era of rock.

The first time I saw the video for Longview I said “those guys are gonna be huge.” Every once in awhile you just know.

dookie was great. 

Everything they've done after was crap. After hearing the stuff they've put out the last 25 years since I can't believe they ever came up with dookie. 

Fuck you guys, they're great, but this sucks, mainly because of the vocals.

Also, they're apparently playing the Rangers' stadium in Arlington, with Fall Out Boy and Weezer.  Who thinks Green Day is a stadium band????

I ilked liked Dookie for about three spins until their fake punk revival ripoff got stale already. They have sucked shit ever since. They are also a prime example of what an absurd pile of crap the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame really is.

2 hours ago, Beau Vine said:

Who thinks Green Day is a stadium band????

Green Day has been a stadium band for 15 years. 

Not sure what to think about this. Has to be the bass player singing, right?  That can't be BJ. And yeah they are processed poppy punk but for fucks sake they invented the genre. So I still like them and fuck you. 

  • Author
8 hours ago, pops said:

Not sure what to think about this. Has to be the bass player singing, right?  That can't be BJ.

It's Billie Joe.  I saw a live clip -- he's doubled, I think by the auxiliary keyboard guy.

12 hours ago, ztejas said:

Green Day has been a stadium band for 15 years. 

They weren't selling out *arenas* on their last tour, and the two times they played in MLB stadiums, they had 10K+ unsold tickets:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_Radio_Tour

The American Idiot tour played ZERO stadiums.

Shit, when they came to Austin in 2013, they played Moody Theatre.  

11 hours ago, pops said:

Not sure what to think about this. Has to be the bass player singing, right?  That can't be BJ. 

 

6 minutes ago, Beau Vine said:

The American Idiot tour played ZERO stadiums.

I mean are we just getting into semantics because American Idiot played plenty of arenas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idiot_World_Tour

Is there a difference between a "stadium band" and an "arena band"? You can't just play "stadiums"

18 minutes ago, ztejas said:

I mean are we just getting into semantics because American Idiot played plenty of arenas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idiot_World_Tour

Is there a difference between a "stadium band" and an "arena band"? You can't just play "stadiums"

Stadium = where football or baseball teams play, min capacity = 30K

Arena = where basketball or hockey teams play, max capacity = 20K

All of the US venues on this Green Day tour are baseball or baseball stadiums.

Not sure why you're being so damn obtuse.

3 minutes ago, Beau Vine said:

Stadium = where football or baseball teams play, min capacity = 30K

Arena = where basketball or hockey teams play, max capacity = 20K

All of the US venues on this Green Day tour are baseball or baseball stadiums.

Not sure why you're being so damn obtuse.

I'm not being obtuse I just didn't know there was much of a difference between a "stadium" band and "arena" band. I get your point now. 

I am going against the grain here, and I don't hate this at all.  I also think American Idiot is a spectacular piece of work.  

On 9/20/2019 at 1:23 PM, Beau Vine said:

Stadium = where football or baseball teams play, min capacity = 30K

Arena = where basketball or hockey teams play, max capacity = 20K

All of the US venues on this Green Day tour are baseball or baseball stadiums.

Not sure why you're being so damn obtuse.

they are playing Minute Maid Park in Houston next August, and have played large stadiums at times in the past.  I wouldn't say they're a perennial stadium band, but certainly they can play those venues in certain markets.  

They are touring with weezer and fall out boy next summer

Green Day is a hippodrome band you fucking twats.

I ilked liked Dookie for about three spins until their fake punk revival ripoff got stale already. They have sucked shit ever since. They are also a prime example of what an absurd pile of crap the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame really is.


Eventually every guitars/drums/vox band will be in the R&R HoF because they are running out of rock bands. 10 years from now they’ll be inducting the Lumineers and Cage the Elephant.
4 hours ago, pepper brooks said:

they are playing Minute Maid Park in Houston next August, and have played large stadiums at times in the past.  I wouldn't say they're a perennial stadium band, but certainly they can play those venues in certain markets.  

They weren't selling out *arenas* on their last tour, and the two times they played in MLB stadiums, they had 10K+ unsold tickets:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_Radio_Tour

The American Idiot tour played ZERO stadiums.

Shit, when they came to Austin in 2013, they played Moody Theatre. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.