Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Damn, that looks delicious.  I use margherita or cheese pies to judge a new joint.  Yours looks fantastic.  I was surprised you put fresh basil on the uncooked pie, but it appears your cook temp is high enough to get the cook time down and not torch the basil.

  • Replies 1.1k
  • Views 104.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

Posted Images

@52-80 that crust looks great, will you share the recipe? I tried a new dough recipe a week or so ago and it was a huge fail! Not sure what went wrong, damn sure aggravating to proof it for 72 hours and never make it to the oven.

9 hours ago, RMac5 said:

@52-80 that crust looks great, will you share the recipe? I tried a new dough recipe a week or so ago and it was a huge fail! Not sure what went wrong, damn sure aggravating to proof it for 72 hours and never make it to the oven.

sorry im cheating here because i have a local bakery company that sells these as frozen neapolitan dough balls and they come out awesome for me without mess.

previously i experimented with various recipes and had problem with the rise, the handling, or hydration (chronicled upthread).  i tried ooni's classic dough, vito iacopelli's various methods, staedler's, but probably the most successful with from gennaro:

 

I took the Verace Pizza Napoletana class in Naples and their official dough recipe is a great place to start: https://www.pizzanapoletana.org/en/ricetta_pizza_napoletana.  Despite its relatively low hydration, if you use the right flour, it can still be challenging to work with as the flour does a great job of absorbing moisture.  52-80's advice on handling the dough upthread is great.

  • 1 month later...
  • Popular Post

Kids wanted some pizza for their last night before back to school. 

IMG-4939.jpg

IMG-4948.jpg

IMG-4928.jpg

 

2 hours ago, jimmyjazz said:

Do you cater?

will trade pizza for shooting and/or defensive position training. 

  • 1 month later...

saw this at the store and convincing my friend to buy it.

seems heavy and sturdy, has thick ass stone, the stone rotates so you dont have to do it manually, the burner wraps around the oven, AND theres a burner on the bottom to help heat up the stone. super smart design

 

 

1 hour ago, nolongerU2horn said:

first question was what kind of size it can handle. looked it up--16"

The footprint is wide and its a bit of a chonker, not portable like the Oonis. 

I saw that the rotation is powered by tiny plastic-geared motor and batteries. Just having it manual on a central pivot would be more outdoor-appropriate, IMO. 

But still the dual-stone heating and big flame coverage seems like a great idea. 

  • 5 weeks later...

IMG_6942.thumb.jpeg.e4b570bd05edb69fc3cc4367e07f922a.jpegMy girlfriend bought me an Ooni 12” for my birthday. Will be giving it a proper break in this weekend. I’ll post all the pizza fails to document my progress. 

On 12/9/2023 at 12:35 PM, elfenix said:

so the usual culprits for hard crust is baking too long/hot, too little water, not enough rise, too little dough, low hyrdation, overkneading, and too much oil.  could be other factors as well. don't remember if you're here in texas - altitude does all sorts of things to baking recipes. 

https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/learn/resources/high-altitude-baking

 

luna pizzeria in houston well sell you a ball of dough, $2 I think 

9 hours ago, Pescado_Rojo said:

IMG_6942.thumb.jpeg.e4b570bd05edb69fc3cc4367e07f922a.jpegMy girlfriend bought me an Ooni 12” for my birthday. Will be giving it a proper break in this weekend. I’ll post all the pizza fails to document my progress. 

Nice.  There's a store on ebay that will make little foot cups you can screw into the table top so it doesn't accidentally get bumped and fall off the table.  Good insurance.  Enjoy!

  • 2 months later...
  • Popular Post

KLA's Chicago thin crust

PXL_20241231_233333435_MP.thumb.jpg.3e30958a085346976dc0c22c88f624fc.jpg

PXL_20250101_235905985_MP.thumb.jpg.e8042d5b7a43cfb6e1f60fcb9ac27095.jpg

PXL_20250102_001941011_MP.thumb.jpg.4c750380276699d9f11166ebc9c3e04d.jpg

PXL_20250102_002429379_MP.thumb.jpg.b366694ed6ff6e5c6631fef740983252.jpg

PXL_20250102_005715949_MP.thumb.jpg.9d3b4232471f3c2207bfb0fbb13d6ede.jpg

 

Notes: first pie cooked close to 9 minutes, turned at 7. It slid off the parchment doing the toss. Second pie cooked 8 with a turn at 6:30, crust ended up more tender. Sauce amount per pie was about 6 heavy tablespoons. Needs more. Sauce is very herb heavy. Will probably cut by half or more next time.

Edited by elfenix

44 minutes ago, CycleTex87 said:

Pepperoni looks tasty.  I prefer less sauce honestly.

Correct. It’s a binder not a topping. 

5 minutes ago, ChickenSandwich said:

Correct. It’s a binder not a topping. 

Robert Downey Jr Yes GIF

20 hours ago, CycleTex87 said:

Pepperoni looks tasty.  I prefer less sauce honestly.

Boars head stick cut on mandoline at 3 mm. 

 

Normally it do as well but it was a bit dry.

Just now, hobbes2702 said:

Oh No What GIF by MasterChefAU

If I die of horrible death in the next couple days, we'll know why.

I'm more heavy on the sauce, light on the cheese.  I also hate kittens.

  • 5 weeks later...

Two pies tonight. First was a blue cheese pizza with caramelized onion, prosciutto and a figure spread with a dash of red pepper flakes. Delicious but very rich.

 

Second, a more traditional italian sausage with the remainder of the caramelized onions.....could of left it in the oven another 30 seconds. Tasty still.

20250202_184103.jpg

20250202_193404.jpg

Yeah I struggle with the dough, and I consider myself a pretty good hand in the kitchen. Those pizzas look damn good.

  • 3 weeks later...

Pulled some dough out of the freezer and then went outside in the freezer to cook a couple. I'll be damned if these didn't cook up nice. Might be something to the cold ass ambient temps holding the temps in check so I can run a longer cook time. Dough was the weak spot here, but I just didn't get around to thinking about pizza early enough to pull out a quick dough batch. And it was too fucking cold outside to run to the WF and pick up a fresh ball. 

 

IMG-7018.jpg

IMG-7023.jpg

IMG-7021.jpg

 

On 2/2/2025 at 7:43 PM, Irwin F Fletcher said:

Two pies tonight. First was a blue cheese pizza with caramelized onion, prosciutto and a figure spread with a dash of red pepper flakes. Delicious but very rich.

 

Second, a more traditional italian sausage with the remainder of the caramelized onions.....could of left it in the oven another 30 seconds. Tasty still.

20250202_184103.jpg

 

One of my favorite topping combinations. I add the blu cheese after cooking for a stronger blue cheese flavor. 

21 minutes ago, ChickenSandwich said:

Where are you guys finding whole milk mozzarella? (Not fresh, just not skim/2%)

deli case

31 minutes ago, ChickenSandwich said:

Of Course Makes Sense GIF

At HEB it's boars head so... Careful

Made some 72 hour pizza dough, it was just okay. I think I need to increase my hydration level to around 64%

I also let my fire temp have to big of swings. Anyway, pizza’s tasted good, just still need more dough work and practice.

917833A1-6221-4C13-AB01-018D0119010D.jpeg

DE56D1E5-1DA0-44FB-943B-EF7A98958A72.jpeg

EB5DF141-6897-4566-9157-C5CB945DC300.jpeg

On 1/1/2025 at 7:04 PM, elfenix said:

KLA's Chicago thin crust

PXL_20241231_233333435_MP.thumb.jpg.3e30958a085346976dc0c22c88f624fc.jpg

PXL_20250101_235905985_MP.thumb.jpg.e8042d5b7a43cfb6e1f60fcb9ac27095.jpg

PXL_20250102_001941011_MP.thumb.jpg.4c750380276699d9f11166ebc9c3e04d.jpg

PXL_20250102_002429379_MP.thumb.jpg.b366694ed6ff6e5c6631fef740983252.jpg

PXL_20250102_005715949_MP.thumb.jpg.9d3b4232471f3c2207bfb0fbb13d6ede.jpg

 

Notes: first pie cooked close to 9 minutes, turned at 7. It slid off the parchment doing the toss. Second pie cooked 8 with a turn at 6:30, crust ended up more tender. Sauce amount per pie was about 6 heavy tablespoons. Needs more. Sauce is very herb heavy. Will probably cut by half or more next time.

Chicago tavern style thin crust is one of my favorites and it only works eaten right out of the oven, so I only get it when I can eat on site.  Steaming in a box kills it.

when can we head over.  I’ll eat and won’t stay long.  Looks great.  Excellent effortingazation

On 2/23/2025 at 7:58 PM, ChickenSandwich said:

Where are you guys finding whole milk mozzarella? (Not fresh, just not skim/2%)

HEB and Randalls both have shredded product if that's your jam.  For block, Randalls has Tillamook and house brand (Lucerne).  Otherwise, deli case.

 

Edited by jimmyjazz

50 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said:

HEB and Randalls both have shredded product if that's your jam.  For block, Randalls has Tillamook and house brand (Lucerne).  Otherwise, deli case.

All good. Walmart actually has a decent whole milk if you can find it.  And, Sargento has a whole milk as well.

image.jpeg.489e2d75f3e0ce89bd14d04df2fe1312.jpeg

Edited by LosIllini

6 minutes ago, LosIllini said:

And, Sargento has a whole milk as well.

Yeah, that was the HEB reference, I wasn't clear.  I don't think Randalls sells it.  (They sell Sargento but I haven't seen that particular product, it probably depends on the store.)

I've given up on making my own dough.  Best dough I have found is the HEB Central Market frozen dough balls.  I've tried the Trader Joe's and I think the HEB stuff is better.  On the Roccbox, I wish the heat was more "indirect."  The flame blazing down on the pie cooks the toppings a little too much before the crust is where I want it.  I sometimes hold the peel over the topping to block the flame from overcooking the toppings.  I have also tried to parbake the dough, but it doesn't come out as good when I do this.  

16 minutes ago, cabowabo said:

I've given up on making my own dough.  Best dough I have found is the HEB Central Market frozen dough balls.  I've tried the Trader Joe's and I think the HEB stuff is better. 

Haven't tried the Central Market dough, but I agree that the Trader Joe's product is lacking.  Randalls has a better one.

4 hours ago, cabowabo said:

I've given up on making my own dough.  Best dough I have found is the HEB Central Market frozen dough balls.  I've tried the Trader Joe's and I think the HEB stuff is better.  On the Roccbox, I wish the heat was more "indirect."  The flame blazing down on the pie cooks the toppings a little too much before the crust is where I want it.  I sometimes hold the peel over the topping to block the flame from overcooking the toppings.  I have also tried to parbake the dough, but it doesn't come out as good when I do this.  

Maybe throw a loose piece of foil on top. 

23 hours ago, jimmyjazz said:

Haven't tried the Central Market dough, but I agree that the Trader Joe's product is lacking.  Randalls has a better one.

How do you know it's a holiday? HEB parking lot is empty and Randall's is half full

On 3/3/2025 at 11:59 AM, cabowabo said:

I've given up on making my own dough.  Best dough I have found is the HEB Central Market frozen dough balls.  I've tried the Trader Joe's and I think the HEB stuff is better.  On the Roccbox, I wish the heat was more "indirect."  The flame blazing down on the pie cooks the toppings a little too much before the crust is where I want it.  I sometimes hold the peel over the topping to block the flame from overcooking the toppings.  I have also tried to parbake the dough, but it doesn't come out as good when I do this.  

Do you have any temp control with the roccboxx? The ooni koda has some adjustability, and esp when doing big pies I always turn it all the way down to get the crust where it needs to be. Turn it up towards the end if necessary to finish the topping and brown up the crust. 

32 minutes ago, Anastasis said:

Do you have any temp control with the roccboxx? The ooni koda has some adjustability, and esp when doing big pies I always turn it all the way down to get the crust where it needs to be. Turn it up towards the end if necessary to finish the topping and brown up the crust. 

Yeah, there is.  I turn it full blast to get it screaming hot, and then turn it down right before launch.  Even at the lowest setting, there is still a good amount of flame the fans out over the ceiling area of the oven.  

On 3/4/2025 at 8:49 PM, cabowabo said:

Yeah, there is.  I turn it full blast to get it screaming hot, and then turn it down right before launch.  Even at the lowest setting, there is still a good amount of flame the fans out over the ceiling area of the oven.  

On the ooni i do 3 things to get the bottom heat in balance with the top (at lowest setting): preheat longer; flip/rotate the stone during preheat; and cook the pie at the front of the oven away from the rear flames. 

It also helps to do neapolitan pies that have much thinner crust

 

I followed some advice on this thread and turned down the flames to allow for a longer cook time without incinerating the crust - I'll definitely be doing it more.

image.jpeg.5dae039322c2f9cb84cb5a26f450620b.jpeg

  • 1 month later...

NSIAP, but TIL that if you own an Ooni, and are thinking about getting a newer/bigger model, you can just fill out an online form with the SN and they will send you a 20% off code for the new purchase.

I’m eyeing the Koda 2 Max. I don’t want to make bigger pizzas than I do in my Karu 12, BUT I recently read an article that mentioned that an overlooked benefit of a larger oven is that you can move the pizza around to different spots as you turn it, so it’s on a hotter stone longer, which makes sense.

  • 2 weeks later...
On 5/4/2025 at 1:19 AM, scottsins said:

NSIAP, but TIL that if you own an Ooni, and are thinking about getting a newer/bigger model, you can just fill out an online form with the SN and they will send you a 20% off code for the new purchase.

I’m eyeing the Koda 2 Max. I don’t want to make bigger pizzas than I do in my Karu 12, BUT I recently read an article that mentioned that an overlooked benefit of a larger oven is that you can move the pizza around to different spots as you turn it, so it’s on a hotter stone longer, which makes sense.


the 16s also have more directional heat than the 12s, so theres probably less rotating required. maybe theres less efficiency due to larger chamber but i dont know if anyones ever compared. 

This new one I got is 24”. Fucking MONSTER. You’re probably right about the rotation, but I will definitely move it around to keep it in contact with hotter surface.

On 5/12/2025 at 1:17 AM, 52-80 said:


the 16s also have more directional heat than the 12s, so theres probably less rotating required. maybe theres less efficiency due to larger chamber but i dont know if anyones ever compared. 

You're rotating pretty regularly on the 16" Koda, even with the fire dialed down.  You don't walk away, in any event.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.