Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Football ... Basketball ... Baseball ... Other Sports ... Futbol ... 🤫995🤫 ... Gambling ... Movies & TV ... Music ... Hobbies ... Lulz ... Food & Travel ... Daily Texan ... Business & Markets ... Cloak Room ... Help ... For Sale ... Board Discussion ... Advertise... Tailgate Donations

Featured Replies

The Big 3 are obviously Breaking Bad, The Sopranos, and The Wire.

Leaving them out, what is the best tv show of all time?

The Americans is the second greatest drama right after Breaking Bad. The Wire is a close third. The Sopranos is a distant fourth.

Seinfeld as a series deserves to go between 2nd and 3rd. Curb should go somewhere in there too, but I'm not sure where yet.

  • Author

I'll go way outside the box on this one and say The Americans.  Great writing, great acting, constant slow burn tension punctuated by crazy shit, and they stuck the landing as well as any show in history with a fantastic finale.  I'll watch this series all the way through at least two more times.

4 minutes ago, TexArcher said:

The Big 3 are obviously Breaking Bad, The Sopranos, and The Wire.

Leaving them out, what is the best tv show of all time?

in the modern era of tv dramas (the past 20-25 years) i would add mad men, the west wing, lost, and the shield to that mix.

  • Author

Hahaha, not as far outside the box as I thought, apparently.  Kudos to you on your correctness and timing, HornOnTheBayou.

Edited by TexArcher

star trek and dr who

 

Edited by tx 3 putt

11 minutes ago, pyrohornIII said:

MASH

The thing I liked so much about MASH was that it didn’t matter which actor they lost, they just got better.  After Larry linville, I thought the show would go down quite a bit, but Ogden stiers did such a good job with the Major Winchester role.  The writing was the real star of course.  I really enjoyed the crazy visiting generals, and. Colonel Flagg. The only time the writing needed a boost I think was at the end.  That show needed the return of Flagg and some funny lines.  The show was taking itself way too seriously by then.  MASH is only the 3rd finale I remember, and the most watched prime time finale ever.  MASH lasted almost 4 times as long as the war it depicted.

I would include Madmen and make it the Big 4.

after that The Leftovers and Deadwood 

sleeper pick, depending on how it finishes-The Expanse

If ur including all tv shows, there is no greater one than simpsons seasons 2-10

 

no show has had a greater impact on american society

I don't know exactly where I would put the line, but I think there needs to be a distinction between "all time TV shows" like MASH and Have Gun Will Tuttle or whatever, and more modern, "prestige TV" serials. 

I totally agree with The Big Three as listed above (BB and The Wire switch places as 1A and 1B for me, Sopranos is 3, though I wouldn't argue with anyone about the order of these three). 

I can't really think of anything else that even belongs in the conversation. I haven't seen Mad Men, but it seems to be the next best thing according to most people. GoT and Deadwood were great until they weren't (and for dramatically different reasons, obviously), but they don't measure up. 

I have really enjoyed Fargo, True Detective, and Legion (I think it's brilliant, but it's not for everyone) yet I certainly wouldn't argue that they belong in the conversation. Maybe Fargo ultimately will deserve to be in the "next 4-10 range" but the other two don't.

What's left? Justified? Charming characters, some good writing and intrigue, but nope. Better Call Saul? Jury is still out, but I don't see it reaching the same level of acclaim as BB. Maybe The X-Files, but the "conspiracy" storyline was too dense and annoying. 

I don't think there is anything yet that clearly deserves the #4 spot.

Edited by Prepuce of Doom

Six Feet Under is really underrated on these lists. Totally unique and terrific drama. The Leftovers was a masterpiece. Mad Men was terrific for four seasons and then was not near as good for the last three. The Americans absolutely belongs. Great from start to finish. 

The thing I liked so much about MASH was that it didn’t matter which actor they lost, they just got better.  After Larry linville, I thought the show would go down quite a bit, but Ogden stiers did such a good job with the Major Winchester role.  The writing was the real star of course.  I really enjoyed the crazy visiting generals, and. Colonel Flagg. The only time the writing needed a boost I think was at the end.  That show needed the return of Flagg and some funny lines.  The show was taking itself way too seriously by then.  MASH is only the 3rd finale I remember, and the most watched prime time finale ever.  MASH lasted almost 4 times as long as the war it depicted.


I’m not sure it got better because I’ve always thought Trapper/Burns/Col Blake MASH was substantially better than Winchester/Col Potter MASH.

The Shield is up there.  Both for its' quality (and fantastic ending) and the influence it had on what basic cable could do.

The Shield was good but a top 25 type good.

I always thought MASH was the GOAT until The Wire came out but I wouldn't rank The Wire over MASH. Shows that good just go into the Hall of Fame. Anyways, MASH can't be ranked because it sits above the top 3.

12 hours ago, TexArcher said:

The Big 3 are obviously Breaking Bad, The Sopranos, and The Wire.

Leaving them out, what is the best tv show of all time?

To me, the obvious answer is The Simpsons. Longevity, quality, great writing. 

Everything else is just who gets second place. 

The Americans is not even in the top ten.  I was out by the end of the first season. 

Maybe it got better but I couldn't stay with it.

Fight me!

26 minutes ago, Asithappens said:

To me, the obvious answer is The Simpsons. Longevity, quality, great writing. 

Everything else is just who gets second place. 

Sadly, the Simpsons has been very bad for nearly 20 years now.

59 minutes ago, C-Man said:

 


I’m not sure it got better because I’ve always thought Trapper/Burns/Col Blake MASH was substantially better than Winchester/Col Potter MASH.

 

Imo, it got better because the writers were able to adapt the script to fit the actors.  Example, the basic theme being cheating people is bad:  Burns cheated soldiers out of money by listening to a baseball game, betting the results with enlisted men and making $ when the game was replayed.  Winchester's character attempted to cheat the locals of their money during the script change episode.   The Winchester episode was a better example I believe, because of the way the writers showed Winchester's emotions when he realized he had been had by Hawkeye and BJ, who used Winchester's words against him in the end, offering 10 cents on the dollar, the exact rate Winchester had offered to the locals.  

I think better writing, because we got to see the gamut of emotions from Winchester.  

 

Imma go outside the box with "She's the Sheriff" and "Small Wonder."  Both highly underrated.  

mjycm-8FY1EB2894F-Full-Image_GalleryBack

Never jumped the shark.  And every episode shot live, no record and final edit.

2 hours ago, usmc0331horn said:

Mad Men was terrific for four seasons and then was not near as good for the last three.

i didn't love the last couple seasons on first watch, but really like them a lot more now.  signal 30 is in season 5 and might be the best episode of the series, so maybe you're thinking it was great for 5/7?  i don't know.

there were definitely a couple of seasons of sopranos that were garbage.  and don't even get me started on the 5th season of the wire.  which isn't even a conversation.  because that season doesn't exist.

if we're strictly talking dramas, seasons 1-4 of west wing (89 eps), 1-4 of the wire (50), 1-5 of mad men (65), pretty much all of breaking bad (62), 1-4 of sopranos (52), 1-3 of lost (70) - are all top fucking notch.

again, i'm talking dramas over the past 25 years.  tv has changed so much, it's impossible to compare eras.

1 hour ago, orangecat92 said:

Imo, it got better because the writers were able to adapt the script to fit the actors.  Example, the basic theme being cheating people is bad:  Burns cheated soldiers out of money by listening to a baseball game, betting the results with enlisted men and making $ when the game was replayed.  Winchester's character attempted to cheat the locals of their money during the script change episode.   The Winchester episode was a better example I believe, because of the way the writers showed Winchester's emotions when he realized he had been had by Hawkeye and BJ, who used Winchester's words against him in the end, offering 10 cents on the dollar, the exact rate Winchester had offered to the locals.  

I think better writing, because we got to see the gamut of emotions from Winchester.  

 

Perhaps -- I just thought it worked better as a comedy with Trapper and Burns. I'm also a MASH movie >>>> M*A*S*H tv show guy.

Perhaps -- I just thought it worked better as a comedy with Trapper and Burns. I'm also a MASH movie >>>> M*A*S*H tv show guy.

Avatar checks out.
10 minutes ago, C-Man said:

Perhaps -- I just thought it worked better as a comedy with Trapper and Burns. I'm also a MASH movie >>>> M*A*S*H tv show guy.

The bookfag of MASH

6 minutes ago, DDD Dad said:


Avatar checks out.

LULZ -- didn't even think of that!

I really liked V from the 80s. Have no idea if it holds up now in any way. 

It doesn’t.


5 minutes ago, DDD Dad said:


It doesn’t.

 

 

 

 

 

Oh shit that was great. Not in a good way.

leftovers

shield

justified

seinfeld

5 hours ago, usmc0331horn said:

Six Feet Under is really underrated on these lists. Totally unique and terrific drama. 

We missed it the first time around, and we tried watching it a couple of years ago. The premise was entertaining, but some of the characters were just such a fucking beating. Jeremy Sisto's angsty tormented stalker guy, Dexter the closeted weirdo, etc. The only people that didn't suck to some degree were the high school daughter and the periodically appearing Ghost Dad (not Bill Cosby). The drama about Dexter's gayness really didn't age well, and while I understand that it was probably fairly groundbreaking at the time, it was a chore to endure nowadays. 

It does not hold up well, and we bailed somewhere between 30-50% of the way through. It was a real relief to be done with what eventually began to feel like an obligation. 

2 hours ago, Prepuce of Doom said:

We missed it the first time around, and we tried watching it a couple of years ago. The premise was entertaining, but some of the characters were just such a fucking beating. Jeremy Sisto's angsty tormented stalker guy, Dexter the closeted weirdo, etc. The only people that didn't suck to some degree were the high school daughter and the periodically appearing Ghost Dad (not Bill Cosby). The drama about Dexter's gayness really didn't age well, and while I understand that it was probably fairly groundbreaking at the time, it was a chore to endure nowadays. 

It does not hold up well, and we bailed somewhere between 30-50% of the way through. It was a real relief to be done with what eventually began to feel like an obligation. 

The first season was greatness.  Then they started concentrating more of the alive characters than the recently deceased.  That was the best part, how the stories of the dead influenced the lives of the family.  But when they got away from that, it turned more into a soap opera and lost it. 

6 hours ago, Asithappens said:

To me, the obvious answer is The Simpsons. Longevity, quality, great writing. 

what is your understanding of longevity and quality wrt the simpsons?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...
Football ... Basketball ... Baseball ... Other Sports ... Futbol ... 🤫995🤫 ... Gambling ... Movies & TV ... Music ... Hobbies ... Lulz ... Food & Travel ... Daily Texan ... Business & Markets ... Cloak Room ... Help ... For Sale ... Board Discussion ... Advertise... Tailgate Donations

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.