Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Huh, I  didn't see that coming.

Spoiler

I had picked up through the ether that the 2nd game was...divisive but had avoided any specific spoilers.  I deliberately bookfagged it up in anticipation of the GOT show so I guess this was my version of the Ned Stark experience.  I'll agree with others that it's hard to see the show continue on without Pascal but we'll see I guess.

The battle sequence was pretty badass.  The mushroom king being able to walk through a flamethrower but die just in time was dumb though.  And I'm not sure I bought those textbook form tackles by the mushroom-seeking german shepherds 

 

Edited by WBT

  • Replies 1.8k
  • Views 136.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Oh god so most of the survivors were gluten free people? I bet the rest of the survivors never stopped hearing about that 

  • Reynolds Woodcock
    Reynolds Woodcock

    Lol at being compelled to fast forward like 10 seconds to avoid seeing gay kissing. T&P

  • Hank_Hill
    Hank_Hill

    “I don’t want to fuck this 14-19 year old so she’s a bad actress” 

Posted Images

We don’t need to spoil discussion about the episode after it’s aired. If you haven’t seen the latest episode, stay the fuck out of the thread. 
 

Only spoiler tag actual gamefag spoilers. 

Just guessing, but I think we're going to see a standalone flashback episode with Catherine O'Haras character and her husband, Eugene. Similar to the Frank and Bill episode from season 1.

For those of you upset with the plot development, I'll just say that I was pretty pissed as well on my first play through of the game. Ended up liking the 2nd game more than the first. Although I get that it was polarizing and not all share my opinion. 

I mean, he pretty much deserved that. Surprising for sure, but I didn’t feel too bad about it.

I have loved Kaitlyn Devers since Justified. She’s a great actress.

Never played the game, but saw that coming.

2 hours ago, A-Tex Devil said:

I guess I don't mind the actress playing Ellie?  She certainly is not attractive, so I guess people are bumping their head on that.  I think she is doing a pretty good job.  She was badass in GoT. 

My issue with her casting isn't with her attractiveness or acting, rather the believability when she inevitably starts killing folks left and right.

She was great in Season 1 and totally believable as a mature for age, smart-mouthed 14 year old.

But now her anger and rage has to carry the show, and it's almost impossible to see her as anything other than a little girl. The toned Abby way, way down from the game version probably to make their rivalry more "fair".

That said, the list of actresses that could believably portray a middle schooler and Terminator 2 Linda Hamilton within two calendar years is probably non-existent.

Edited by aggie08

1 hour ago, Foosters said:

Just guessing, but I think we're going to see a standalone flashback episode with Catherine O'Haras character and her husband, Eugene. Similar to the Frank and Bill episode from season 1.

Yep. I put the over/under at 2.5 for how many more episodes a living, breathing Pascal will appear in.

On 4/20/2025 at 2:32 PM, Baboontyme said:

I'll be that guy. I like Ellie and fuck Joel. You expect her to kiss his ass for 'saving' her? She knows. 

Is Ellie the worst character ever? 

Possibly 

Is Baboontyme the dumbest poster on Surly? 

Possibly 

2 hours ago, Doc Sam Beckett said:

Is Ellie the worst character ever? 

Possibly 

Is Baboontyme the dumbest poster on Surly? 

Possibly 

Animated GIF

But can you please elaborate? Is there really a crowd of Joel worshippers out there, even after his murderous rampage of innocent people who were trying to save humanity? All because Ellie has a forehead that you could fit an aircraft carrier on?

Edited by Baboontyme

  • Author
27 minutes ago, Baboontyme said:

Animated GIF

But can you please elaborate? Is there really a crowd of Joel worshippers out there, even after his murderous rampage of innocent people who were trying to save humanity? All because Ellie has a forehead that you could fit an aircraft carrier on?

It doesn't make any sense in the show, but in the 1st game she was a pretty little non-potato girl that reminded him of his daughter.

2 minutes ago, rage-a-holic said:

It doesn't make any sense in the show, but in the 1st game she was a pretty little non-potato girl that reminded him of his daughter.

Fair. I got hooked into the show with the intro in the pilot and then bought the game because I was liking the show. I actually stopped playing the game because it was spoiler tagging the show. 

She does look like a potato. But I think she's a pretty good actor and liked her in Thrones, too. 

  • Author
11 minutes ago, Baboontyme said:

Fair. I got hooked into the show with the intro in the pilot and then bought the game because I was liking the show. I actually stopped playing the game because it was spoiler tagging the show. 

She does look like a potato. But I think she's a pretty good actor and liked her in Thrones, too. 

I don't think anyone is complaining about her acting skills, its more:

  1. She is extremely unattractive and doesn't look anything like the character in the first game.
  2. For Season 2, she continues to be extremely unattractive and looks nothing like the character in the 2nd game.
  3. The producers of this show were very aware that a lot of viewers were unhappy about casting her. They could easily have recast her role for the 2nd season; instead they said Fuck You to anyone that doesn't like her, we're bringing her back.
On 4/15/2025 at 9:11 AM, faps said:

And that group of zoomers at the beginning were not intimidating in any way, rough acting too. I haven't played any of the games, so maybe it gets better.

this aged well lol

On 4/20/2025 at 8:37 PM, HornOnTheBayou said:

 

  Hide contents

HBO has killed off major characters before. See Stark, Ned. But this one has me scratching my head. Why am I still watching if Joel is dead?

 

Quote
Spoiler

exactly. i don't even like Ellie, and i now hate this new chick, i'm not emotionally invested in Tommy or anybody else, and i've seen zombies before... what's the point now??

 

23 hours ago, aggie08 said:
  Hide contents

I don't know how the game handles it, but "Oh just shut the fuck up and do it already" is a pretty perfect sendoff.

 

i had just uttered the same phrase when he said it 😄

Edited by mchookem

  • Popular Post

“I don’t want to fuck this 14-19 year old so she’s a bad actress” 

Edited by Hank_Hill

20 hours ago, 6th Street said:
  Hide contents

So the rest of the show is now the potato going around looking for the other girl to avenge his death? Terrible. Pedro Pascal is the only reason people watch this show.

 

If only they’d completely changed the source material that got people watching in the first place 😩😩

Edited by Hank_Hill

7 hours ago, rage-a-holic said:

I don't think anyone is complaining about her acting skills, its more:

  1. She is extremely unattractive and doesn't look anything like the character in the first game.
  2. For Season 2, she continues to be extremely unattractive and looks nothing like the character in the 2nd game.
  3. The producers of this show were very aware that a lot of viewers were unhappy about casting her. They could easily have recast her role for the 2nd season; instead they said Fuck You to anyone that doesn't like her, we're bringing her back.

Are you serious about #3? Fine; you don’t find her attractive.  Do you really live in a world where you thought recasting Ellie was even a remote possibility?

  • Popular Post
8 hours ago, rage-a-holic said:

I don't think anyone is complaining about her acting skills, its more:

  1. She is extremely unattractive and doesn't look anything like the character in the first game.
  2. For Season 2, she continues to be extremely unattractive and looks nothing like the character in the 2nd game.
  3. The producers of this show were very aware that a lot of viewers were unhappy about casting her. They could easily have recast her role for the 2nd season; instead they said Fuck You to anyone that doesn't like her, we're bringing her back.

“The 19 year old girl is not as attractive as her teenage video game character” has to land in the top 5 of incel/dweeb crossover posts on Surly. Well done

6 minutes ago, Reynolds Woodcock said:

“The 19 year old girl is not as attractive as her teenage video game character” has to land in the top 5 of incel/dweeb crossover posts on Surly. Well done

It's really even worse than that, given that same character was a child in the previous season. 

I never understood Gamergate at the time, but I'm starting to get it now. 

Fucking weirdos. 

  • Popular Post

I hope she gets uglier as the season goes on.

1 hour ago, Reynolds Woodcock said:

“The 19 year old girl is not as attractive as her teenage video game character” has to land in the top 5 of incel/dweeb crossover posts on Surly. Well done

Reminds me of the Game of Thrones and The Americans threads. Surly old men sure love them some technically legal actresses portraying 15 year olds but who look 12. Not creepy at all.

Reminds me of the Game of Thrones and The Americans threads. Surly old men sure love them some technically legal actresses portraying 15 year olds but who look 12. Not creepy at all.

Who look 12 and can pass as a boy in the actual show. Like they spent a whole season as a boy!
2 hours ago, mdmost said:

I hope she gets uglier as the season goes on.

Serious question: When she smokes that weed, does she become a baked potato? 

I was thinking got too 

 

giant and that thingy Tommy killed breaking through wall. 
 

Walkers running at them. Using fire. 
 

except i could actually see what was happening. 

My question isn't about the looks of a young female actor. I wonder why they didn't flood the pipes with gas to kill the spores instead of opening them up to air.

Can someone please remind me whether there's some kind of "hive mind" or shared consciousness/awareness among the infected? If so, do we know how it works, or any other (non-spoiler) details? 

Or do they all just respond to stimuli in consist and predictable ways? 

3 minutes ago, Prepuce of Doom said:

Can someone please remind me whether there's some kind of "hive mind" or shared consciousness/awareness among the infected? If so, do we know how it works, or any other (non-spoiler) details? 

Or do they all just respond to stimuli in consist and predictable ways? 

It certainly looked that way (they headed towards town once the guy messed with the pipe).

24 minutes ago, RPM said:

My question isn't about the looks of a young female actor. I wonder why they didn't flood the pipes with gas to kill the spores instead of opening them up to air.

They didn't know the fungus was in the sewer pipes.  They thought they were all just clogged with roots.

11 minutes ago, kevwun said:

They didn't know the fungus was in the sewer pipes.  They thought they were all just clogged with roots.

But instead, the fungus was among us? 

29 minutes ago, Prepuce of Doom said:

Can someone please remind me whether there's some kind of "hive mind" or shared consciousness/awareness among the infected? If so, do we know how it works, or any other (non-spoiler) details? 

Or do they all just respond to stimuli in consist and predictable ways? 

Here’s everything you need to know about the infected. This link is specific to the show and not the game which is slightly different 

https://thelastofus.fandom.com/wiki/Infected_(HBO_series)

  • Author
8 hours ago, Hank_Hill said:

“I don’t want to fuck this 14-19 year old so she’s a bad actress” 

You're fucking retarded. No one said she was a bad actress and I specifically pointed that out. She's ugly and miscast. 

Disliking a casting decision does not equal "yOu JuSt wAnT tO fUk sUm LiL GuRL AkTrEss"

For the sake of the show I actually think aging up Ellie to 18-19 in season 1 and having a non-potato actress play her would have been the smarter move. Would have made her much more believable as a survivalist and the added maturity would have made her a lot more interesting/likeable. No one wants to watch two whiny, scrawny “teenagers” cosplaying as zombie-slaying Rambo’s try to carry the show as the leads for the next 8 episodes. 

Should have killed Ellie too. 
 

and then Dina joins that clan. And we see them scissor and survive 

1 hour ago, Helobious said:

For the sake of the show I actually think aging up Ellie to 18-19 in season 1 and having a non-potato actress play her would have been the smarter move. Would have made her much more believable as a survivalist and the added maturity would have made her a lot more interesting/likeable. No one wants to watch two whiny, scrawny “teenagers” cosplaying as zombie-slaying Rambo’s try to carry the show as the leads for the next 8 episodes. 

So the smarter move would have been to make a completely different show than the one they made that adhered to the game characters and timeline? The Godfather would have been so much better if Coppola changed the book and made Sonny the Godfather and Michael opened an antiques store in Connecticut with Kate. Fredo probably becomes a stone cold killer in your idiotic version.

Brilliant suggestion as always, King Potato Head.

Edited by Herpa Derpa

The fixation that some of you fucking weirdos have with not being attracted to the main protagonist that is supposed to be 14 in the first season is very bizarre.

1 hour ago, rage-a-holic said:

May be an image of 4 people and text that says 'I don't think Bella Ramsey was the right choice to play Ellie. drlp-meme.com ne.com drip-meme I'm sorry you don't want to have sex with her! This is how people defend terrible casting.'

Wow this meme is terrible. Congrats.

1 hour ago, rage-a-holic said:

You're fucking retarded. No one said she was a bad actress and I specifically pointed that out. She's ugly and miscast. 

Disliking a casting decision does not equal "yOu JuSt wAnT tO fUk sUm LiL GuRL AkTrEss"

2/3 of your bullet points were regarding her attractiveness. Sure sounds like you’re mad about her unfuckability to me. 

1 minute ago, Hank_Hill said:

2/3 of your bullet points were regarding her attractiveness. Sure sounds like you’re mad about her unfuckability to me. 

He was also complaining about not being attracted to Elle during season 1 when she's supposed to be 14.

Edited by elguapo

9 minutes ago, elguapo said:

The fixation that some of you fucking weirdos have with not being attracted to the main protagonist that is supposed to be 14 in the first season is very bizarre.

Wouldn’t it be weird if they did find her attractive?

  • Author
3 minutes ago, Hank_Hill said:

2/3 of your bullet points were regarding her attractiveness. Sure sounds like you’re mad about her unfuckability to me. 

 

1 minute ago, elguapo said:

He was also complaining about not being attracted to Elle during season 1 when she's supposed to be 14.

May be an image of 4 people and text that says 'I don't think Bella Ramsey was the right choice to play Ellie. drlp-meme.com ne.com drip-meme I'm sorry you don't want to have sex with her! This is how people defend terrible casting.'

Potato or not, the character is unwatchable, annoying, and unrealistic. It’s why I think the writers should’ve gone a very different direction from the game and made her older and more sympathetic. 

8 minutes ago, Helobious said:

Potato or not, the character is unwatchable, annoying, and unrealistic. It’s why I think the writers should’ve gone a very different direction from the game and made her older and more sympathetic. 

Yeah, she's a fine actress and I couldn't give a shit about if she is attractive or not. Her character is a huge entitled asshole

9 minutes ago, Helobious said:

Potato or not, the character is unwatchable, annoying, and unrealistic. It’s why I think the writers should’ve gone a very different direction from the game and made her older and more sympathetic. 

Unrealistic in a zombie show? Holy shit, you truly are a potato head.  Here's a thought. Maybe they can do a second season where the character has physically grown and put her in a story where she's initially a bitchy cunt but circumstances through the season create a much more sympathetic character with an arc that provides psychological growth and is enjoyed by the engaged viewer. Some call that a television show. You apparently need everything every episode because development is beyond your intellectual grasp.

Click back over to SpongeBob which is better suited for your skill level.

This shit is funny.  If she is annoying you she is doing her job as an actress. Who cares if she doesn’t look like the person in the game.  It’s like getting mad they cast different races in LOTR.  The character is a 19 year old orphaned adrenaline junky immune to the infected that doesn’t want to be told what to do.  She’s supposed to be a bit of a cunt.  Bella is doing a fine job. 

Better not watch that Fantastic Four trailer and see who is playing the Silver Surfer!!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.