Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Just saw an email that a local store will have Four Roses Private Selection OBSQ available tomorrow for $70/bottle.

Has anyone tried it, or prior "Private Selection" releases, and is it worth trying to get a bottle or two?

  • Replies 21.8k
  • Views 1.7m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I’m exhausted, but she’s basically done... just a few touch ups and a second lamp... then I get to focus on balancing out the left side. Been very thankful to have this as a distraction during COVID,

  • Bigpoppapump
    Bigpoppapump

    Just won the whisky exchange raffle for 20 yr pappy.

  • BigDHornfan
    BigDHornfan

    Having a pour of my favorite in honor of my girl. Hanna gave me 16 great years. RIP girl. Hope you finally got that fucking squirrel.

Posted Images

13 minutes ago, AnonymousInternetPoster said:

Just saw an email that a local store will have Four Roses Private Selection OBSQ available tomorrow for $70/bottle.

Has anyone tried it, or prior "Private Selection" releases, and is it worth trying to get a bottle or two?

If it's barrel proof, I would grab one.  I think "Private Selection" implies barrel proof, but not positive.  I think I've had OESF and OESQ before and both were great.  OBSV is the standard single barrel so if you like that, this will be a higher proof and the yeast is supposed to be more "floral".

2 hours ago, TheAuditor said:

Anybody tried Walking Stick SB?  Tried new store and guy behind the counter was pushing.  Picked up a bookers 18-1;  haven't tried it yet though. 

Love the Walking Stick. Good drinking for the price. One of the only NDPs that I got conned into at some point and actually come back for more on occasion. 

Someone got me an early birthday present . It is smooth as fuck 

7991854_A_592_D_4_A27_BEF1_D4634_E393_F0

1 hour ago, billfromlaketravis said:

I was able to nab a bottle of Blood Oath Pact 4. It's not supposed to be as good as previous releases, but I might as well. Houston is bone dry right now.

In lieu of the Blanton's shortage, I'm drinking a Belle Meade Single Barrel, Cask Strength 11 Year. Hey the bottle has a horse on it too. 

The 11 is supposed to be pretty rare. The 10 is also pretty tough to find. 

 

Saw a bottle of blood oath pact 3 the other day. Worth picking up at MSRP?

25 minutes ago, Firemans4Horn said:

 

Saw a bottle of blood oath pact 3 the other day. Worth picking up at MSRP?

Pact 2 is frequently mentioned as the best. 3 is supposed to be a little better than 4. I’d go for it.

12 hours ago, PantsTent said:

If it's barrel proof, I would grab one.  I think "Private Selection" implies barrel proof, but not positive.  I think I've had OESF and OESQ before and both were great.  OBSV is the standard single barrel so if you like that, this will be a higher proof and the yeast is supposed to be more "floral".

Found this as well:

https://flightclubict.com/2017/10/30/four-roses-single-barrel-private-selection-obsq-vs-oesq/

Picked up a bottle of McKenna 10 based on this thread. There were a few bottles at the local specs. No huge demand in the burbs.

Also picked up a bottle of sezerac rye.

18 hours ago, AnonymousInternetPoster said:

Just saw an email that a local store will have Four Roses Private Selection OBSQ available tomorrow for $70/bottle.

Has anyone tried it, or prior "Private Selection" releases, and is it worth trying to get a bottle or two?

 

7 minutes ago, SMUlawUTgrad said:

Picked up a bottle of McKenna 10 based on this thread. There were a few bottles at the local specs. No huge demand in the burbs.

Also picked up a bottle of sezerac rye.

I think you'll enjoy the Sazerac. It's really good for a rye.  I might make it my go daily drinker when Eagle Rare is scarce. 

There's no telling with the McKenna. 

21 hours ago, PantsTent said:

If it's barrel proof, I would grab one.  I think "Private Selection" implies barrel proof, but not positive.  I think I've had OESF and OESQ before and both were great.  OBSV is the standard single barrel so if you like that, this will be a higher proof and the yeast is supposed to be more "floral".

Yes. Private selection equals barrel proof.  And yes it's worth $70 a bottle.  There are 10 variations. OE is a low rye mash bill (by 4 roses standards but still higher than most) and OB is their high rye.  Both mashbills get paired with one of five yeast strains each with a unique character to make the 10 options.  I'm generally prefer the low rye but was surprised by the OBSV (yes same mashbill as the single barrel but at cask strength and with more age).  It may have been one of the best I've had. 

Word of caution.  Thought I've never disliked any of these I've like some substantially more than others. OESO was my least favorite and I think that is the "fruit" profile if I recall correctly   Anyway my point is they're all surprisingly different and the fact that they are single barrel and often aged different lengths and have different proofs makes even the same mashbill somewhat variable   

 

 

 

4 minutes ago, brown water said:

Yes. Private selection equals barrel proof.  And yes it's worth $70 a bottle.  There are 10 variations. OE is a low rye mash bill (by 4 roses standards but still higher than most) and OB is their high rye.  Both mashbills get paired with one of five yeast strains each with a unique character to make the 10 options.  I'm generally prefer the low rye but was surprised by the OBSV (yes same mashbill as the single barrel but at cask strength and with more age).  It may have been one of the best I've had. 

Word of caution.  Thought I've never disliked any of these I've like some substantially more than others. OESO was my least favorite and I think that is the "fruit" profile if I recall correctly   Anyway my point is they're all surprisingly different and the fact that they are single barrel and often aged different lengths and have different proofs makes even the same mashbill somewhat variable   

 

 

 

Totally agree they are all worth the shot if you're a fan of the standard release.  I've only had 3 of the 10...can't remember what the 3rd one was.  I had a goal at one time to get all 10, but I usually just drink everything I buy which is why that will never happen and why I can't remember that other bottle because it's long gone.  It's been a few years though so I need to find one to enjoy.

It would be awesome to get a group together and be able to go try all 10 and pick a barrel, but it's mostly impossible in Texas because you need that 3rd tier.  You'd also need $10-12K to buy the bottled barrel.  Yes, I once did some research....

 

Right now I’ve got OESV, OBSV, OESQ, OBSQ and OESK at the house.  

I’m also debating talking to a local shop about underwriting a private barrel for them.  Don’t tell Mrs. Brown Water. 

1 hour ago, brown water said:

Yes. Private selection equals barrel proof.  And yes it's worth $70 a bottle.  There are 10 variations. OE is a low rye mash bill (by 4 roses standards but still higher than most) and OB is their high rye.  Both mashbills get paired with one of five yeast strains each with a unique character to make the 10 options.  I'm generally prefer the low rye but was surprised by the OBSV (yes same mashbill as the single barrel but at cask strength and with more age).  It may have been one of the best I've had. 

Word of caution.  Thought I've never disliked any of these I've like some substantially more than others. OESO was my least favorite and I think that is the "fruit" profile if I recall correctly   Anyway my point is they're all surprisingly different and the fact that they are single barrel and often aged different lengths and have different proofs makes even the same mashbill somewhat variable   

 

 

 

Picked up a couple of the OBSQ ("Floral, spicy, medium body").  One to drink and one to save.  It is definitely worth $70.  Actually 6 of the 10 varieties have "Fruity" in the description (OBSV, OBSO, OBSF, OESV, OESO and OESF).

Also grabbed a Wild Turkey Decades/Master's Keep.  He gave me the 6 bottle price.  How could I refuse?

Just now, AnonymousInternetPoster said:

Picked up a couple of the OBSQ ("Floral, spicy, medium body").  One to drink and one to save.  It is definitely worth $70.  Actually 6 of the 10 varieties have "Fruity" in the description (OBSV, OBSO, OBSF, OESV, OESO and OESF).

Also grabbed a Wild Turkey Decades/Master's Keep.  He gave me the 6 bottle price.  How could I refuse?

That MK is delightful. 

Just now, BigDHornfan said:

Picked up a Blood Oath at Goody Goody tonight.
Worth the $93?

Pact 4?

13 minutes ago, BigDHornfan said:


Yes

I picked up a bottle of Pact 4 today as well. Pretty cool presentation, I hope the bottle is just as good. I'm optimistic about this brand. The description is written is cursive. There's no way millennial hipsters can decipher it. 

Edited by billfromlaketravis

There's a bottle of James Thompson 45 yr Final Reserve up on the Bourbon Secondary Market fb group right now. Auction goes until Sunday. Current bid is $2200. 

Collectors think it could go for $10-$20K on the secondary market. 

I mean, damn.

https://www.whizzky.net/article.php?ide=163

F me a guy on that group just sold three 750s of Weller 12 for $315 shipped. Crazytown.

Some of the prices listed in that group are incredibly stupid


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

Considering most bourbon peaks at 6-10 years, it’s highly likely that a bourbon barrel aged for 45 years is garbage.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

3 hours ago, Bert Orange said:

That MK is delightful. 

Is it worth the MSRP?

I saw a bottle in the wild but didn’t pull the trigger

3 hours ago, Buzzrock said:

There's a bottle of James Thompson 45 yr Final Reserve up on the Bourbon Secondary Market fb group right now. Auction goes until Sunday. Current bid is $2200. 

Collectors think it could go for $10-$20K on the secondary market. 

I mean, damn.

https://www.whizzky.net/article.php?ide=163

If the proof is above 80, I'm impressed. 

8 hours ago, Neonmoon said:

Is it worth the MSRP?

I saw a bottle in the wild but didn’t pull the trigger

Personally I don’t think so. They priced it about $50 high. But it’s a damn fine bourbon. But I’d happily pay $100 (and I paid $150, because it’s the price of admission if you want to try it). 

11 hours ago, BigDHornfan said:


Yes

I have Pacts 1-3. Pact 1 was turrible. I almost didn’t buy Pact 2 I hated it so much. But Pact 2 is outstanding. I opened Pact 3 a few weeks back and will revisit today after it has breathed a little. Was not blown away by 3 upon first tasting. 

Someone got me an early birthday present . It is smooth as fuck 
7991854_A_592_D_4_A27_BEF1_D4634_E393_F02.jpg

Been looking, never seen it in the wild.
1 hour ago, ousuxndallas said:

Derby time.

346ef6b01ae383aabd567c13ffaef826.jpg3c21413b9208d73f8c0a3976376a018f.jpg

Hold me back bro if you used a  Pappy 12 in a Mint Julep.

If you're balling at that level, Bobby Axelrod wants some stock tips. 

1 hour ago, 'stache said:


Been looking, never seen it in the wild.

Same. I don't think RY10 makes it all the way down to Houston. 

Belle Meade 11 is excellent. Pick it up if available. It's very, very hard to mess up a 11 year old, single barrel.

Hold me back bro if you used a  Pappy 12 in a Mint Julep.
If you're balling at that level, Bobby Axelrod wants some stock tips. 
I'm your huckleberry. My buddy has so much of it, that's what he drinks at derby time.
11 minutes ago, ousuxndallas said:
54 minutes ago, billfromlaketravis said:
Hold me back bro if you used a  Pappy 12 in a Mint Julep.
If you're balling at that level, Bobby Axelrod wants some stock tips. 

I'm your huckleberry. My buddy has so much of it, that's what he drinks at derby time.

Could you introduce me?

Same. I don't think RY10 makes it all the way down to Houston. 
Belle Meade 11 is excellent. Pick it up if available. It's very, very hard to mess up a 11 year old, single barrel.

I think I saw it on Friday at the specs on Bay Area Blvd. I don’t know things or I would have picked it up.
Hold me back bro if you used a  Pappy 12 in a Mint Julep.
If you're balling at that level, Bobby Axelrod wants some stock tips. 

Weller 12 is better than Lot B. Come at me, bro


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
1 hour ago, Bozo_Casanova said:


Weller 12 is better than Lot B. Come at me, bro
 

But which one makes a better julep?

In my opinion neither. I’d use something like like Old Forester 100.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

5dw4tk.jpg

 

The bourbon bar at our daughters wedding yesterday. Obviously the before shot, the after shot was just too sad what with all the empty bottles.  Arturo Fuente robustos, and then a batch of about 20 18 year old vintage Ghurkas showed up to round out the setting.

Some of the prices listed in that group are incredibly stupid


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro


Honestly it seems like a joke group.
I'm your huckleberry. My buddy has so much of it, that's what he drinks at derby time.


Tell your buddy that some Internet person says fuck you.
5dw4tk.jpg
 
The bourbon bar at our daughters wedding yesterday. Obviously the before shot, the after shot was just too sad what with all the empty bottles.  Arturo Fuente robustos, and then a batch of about 20 18 year old vintage Ghurkas showed up to round out the setting.


In terms of findable stuff, Russell 10 and Bulleit 10 are pretty good.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.