Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies


I’m on a live album kick for listening around the house. This topic has probably been done before (and is a little different than live performance video), but let’s do it again. These are some good ones, what are your favorites?

Seems like a good time to note that the allman brothers live at the Fillmore East is 50 years old this year and nothing better has ever been pressed to vinyl. 
 

also means that the 50th anniversary of duane’s death is later this year. 
 

 

Edited by Pato del Muerto

5 hours ago, Pato del Muerto said:

Seems like a good time to note that the allman brothers live at the Fillmore East is 50 years old this year and nothing better has ever been pressed to vinyl. 
 

also means that the 50th anniversary of duane’s death is later this year. 
 

 

I have that. I also have Live at Ludlow Garage and Live at the Atlanta International Pop Festival. I also have/had several live bootlegs. You know what sucks about each of them? A half hour long self-indulgent Mountain Jam that doesn’t really do anything for me. (And on the Atlanta discs you get two of them!) Talk about giving a bad name to drum solos. Are you telling me you listen to that Mountain Jam every time you listen to the album? Or do you skip past it?

The best one they did was with the Dead at Watkins Glen on 7/28/73.

It’s a great album. I wouldn’t say it’s the best ever. But anything with “Live at the Fillmore” attached to it is going to be solid. It’s no better than Derek and the Dominos Live at the Fillmore (which is awesome). Or Miles Davis. Or any number of Dead shows...from both coasts. But it’s hard to use the Dead when talking about live albums because they were a live band and have more live releases than most bands have albums and even more freely available live bootlegs than that.

Also, The Last Waltz is one of the greatest live albums/films/performances of all time. 

I used to have a VHS tape of the Allmans on MTV Unplugged. That was the first time I ever saw Warren Haynes. He was dressed nicely and his hair was long and pretty. (Come to think of it, I might be misremembering that and it may have been a concert on HBO.) I got to see him differently in bars and small clubs when he was playing with Gov’t Mule back when Allen Woody was still alive. Man, those shows rocked. They jammed hard.

But speaking of MTV Unplugged, this is one of my favorite live albums:

 

Edited by WhatTheBuck

Also, from the ‘88 tour, Frank’s last “rock”/electric tour and one of the most talented big bands ever. Four discs of greatness.

1601644798_cover.jpg

when-yuppies-go-to-hell-zappa.jpg?w=500&

Edited by WhatTheBuck

Four more discs. After Robert Fripp went years without performing or recording, he finally won his lawsuit against the record label over the rights to his music. He put a new King Crimson together, a double trio format adding Trey Gunn and Pat Mastelotto to the 80’s Crimson lineup of Fripp, Belew, Levin, and Bruford. Those were heady times. At one point my King Crimson collection consisted of just the ten CD’s that were available. Then new Crimson material started coming out, I got to see them live, and Robert opened up the vaults. The first live release was The Great Deceiver, all from ‘73 and ‘74 which I consider to be the peak era of rock music. The music made during that period is pretty amazing and, if not ‘73 or ‘74, ‘’72 and ‘75 come pretty damn close. I now own dozens and dozens of Crimson discs, many of them live and spanning four decades. But it’s worth noting which shows an artist releases first. These are really, really good. (Also, the studio albums King Crimson released in ‘73 and ‘74 were Larks’ Tongues in Aspic and Statless and Bible Black, respectively, and they’re both awesome.)

8346_king_crimson_the_great_deceiver.jpg

Grateful Dead 5/8/77 from Barton Hall on the Cornell University campus.

  • Author

I finally watched Last Waltz not too long ago and enjoyed it but it was extremely difficult for me to make it through Joni Mitchell's bit. Maybe it's a generational thing, maybe I've just suffered through too many talentless people trying to do that kind of thing but goddamn I can't stand it. I need to listen to some of The Band's other live stuff as well.

31 minutes ago, Celery Man said:

I finally watched Last Waltz not too long ago and enjoyed it but it was extremely difficult for me to make it through Joni Mitchell's bit. Maybe it's a generational thing, maybe I've just suffered through too many talentless people trying to do that kind of thing but goddamn I can't stand it. I need to listen to some of The Band's other live stuff as well.

If you can’t dig Coyote then there’s something seriously wrong with you.

 

  • Author

I like her guitar strap but otherwise yeah I’m fucked up, I hate that so much

that's because it's terrible. instant skip every time. 

1 hour ago, Celery Man said:

I need to listen to some of The Band's other live stuff as well.

 

1 hour ago, stc said:

that's because it's terrible. instant skip every time. 

I assume you also skip past Neil Diamond. What else do you skip past?

5 minutes ago, Rip76 said:

AE5B1BAC-7745-49EE-8DCA-75E488943BA4.jpeg

I originally got a copy of this recording from a friend in Cleveland who won a CD copy in a radio contest (from WMMS - home of the buzzard). Rush later made it an official release. But I don’t think it included the interview with Donna Halper. It also featured their first live performance of Working Man.

 

Also, notice that Rush jammed back then. Not in the sense of full band improvisation like the Dead, the prototypical jam band. But in terms of stretching out solo passages by a few bars. Everyone did that back then. Eventually Rush would become a band that played beat-for-beat and note-for-note identical reproductions of the album versions of their songs. And when I was in high school I thought that was a sign of a good band. And, granted, a lot of bands couldn’t even manage to do that. Neil Peart (who wasn’t the drummer in ‘74) was amazing but it wasn’t until late in his life that he tried to loosen up and depart from his metronomic precision. I respect that he tried. I don’t think he ever really got there. His forte was technical precision. Groove and swing were never his thing. 

5 hours ago, mbtex said:

lynyrd-skynyrd_one-more-from-the-road_24.jpg

 

 

Cover Fandango! (Remastered)

Fandango should have a double album. It felt incomplete when released, it still feels incomplete. 

25 minutes ago, WhatTheBuck said:

Also, notice that Rush jammed back then. Not in the sense of full band improvisation like the Dead, the prototypical jam band. But in terms of stretching out solo passages by a few bars. Everyone did that back then. Eventually Rush would become a band that played beat-for-beat and note-for-note identical reproductions of the album versions of their songs. And when I was in high school I thought that was a sign of a good band. And, granted, a lot of bands couldn’t even manage to do that. Neil Peart (who wasn’t the drummer in ‘74) was amazing but it wasn’t until late in his life that he tried to loosen up and depart from his metronomic precision. I respect that he tried. I don’t think he ever really got there. His forte was technical precision. Groove and swing were never his thing. 

He did not get there, and I’m totally ok with that.

25 minutes ago, Scooter Monzingo said:

Fandango should have a double album. It felt incomplete when released, it still feels incomplete. 

Fully agree with this.

JC at Folsom (already mentioned)

Neil Young Live Rust

Jerry Lee Lewis at the Star Club

Pink Floyd Is There Anybody Out There

Springsteen Live 75-85

AC/DC Live (91 tour)

 

21 hours ago, Pato del Muerto said:

Seems like a good time to note that the allman brothers live at the Fillmore East is 50 years old this year and nothing better has ever been pressed to vinyl. 
 

also means that the 50th anniversary of duane’s death is later this year. 
 

 

This is the correct answer.

I know no one likes them anymore, but this is really good and has a lot of improvisation, flea playing trumpet on one song etc...

R.8b84b39147eb1e1a96cd0a044e6e21c8?rik=a

4 hours ago, Rip76 said:

He did not get there, and I’m totally ok with that.

He was still a musical genius. May he rest in peace. First concert I ever saw was Rush on the Signals tour at Notre Dame in 1982. I got up at 5 AM, skipped the first half of school and drove to South Bend to wait in line at the box office to buy tickets. My mom didn’t know about it. I was a good student and none of my teachers whose classes I missed ever said a word about it. I did that a few more times while I was in high school to see Styx, REO Speedwagon, Billy Joel, and Journey. There was a sense of adventure about it that inspired me to a long and illustrious concert going career. 

3 hours ago, GopherRock said:

spacer.png

Speaking more about Zappa and the ‘88 tour, Frank met Johnny Cash one day at the hotel and Johnny was going to come sit in with them but his wife got sick and he couldn’t make it (so the story goes, anyway). But the band worked up Ring of Fire in the afternoon and performed it that night. (Pay no attention to the video, that’s from a different performance and if I cared at all I could tell you what it is. I’ve probably posted it elsewhere on this board before.)

Zappa also met Sting on the ‘88 tour and he did show up to perform Murder By Numbers with the band.  I’ve definitely posted this before. (NSFW; there’s one F-bomb.)

 

1 hour ago, WhatTheBuck said:

He was still a musical genius. May he rest in peace. First concert I ever saw was Rush on the Signals tour at Notre Dame in 1982. I got up at 5 AM, skipped the first half of school and drove to South Bend to wait in line at the box office to buy tickets. My mom didn’t know about it. I was a good student and none of my teachers whose classes I missed ever said a word about it. I did that a few more times while I was in high school to see Styx, REO Speedwagon, Billy Joel, and Journey. There was a sense of adventure about it that inspired me to a long and illustrious concert going career. 

The Signals tour is the tour I would have most liked to have seen.  Signals may be my most cherished Rush album.  I was 10 when signals came out, and to this day, it still crushes me.

11 minutes ago, Rip76 said:

The Signals tour is the tour I would have most liked to have seen.  Signals may be my most cherished Rush album.  I was 10 when signals came out, and to this day, it still crushes me.

The lasers blew me away. My ears were still ringing when I went to bed that night. 

Wow. No one? Really? Maybe it's too cliche of an answer. 

71MrzFvKH2L._SX466_.jpg.c4f60bf0148098060c0d4e26fff5ab58.jpg

If we were doing greatest songs recorded live Do You Feel has to be very very high up the list... one of the coolest artist and audiences exchanges ever put on vinyl. Just a masterful read of timing and energy accompanied with some near flawless picking. 

Also this - which I might put #1. 

Neil_Young_Rust_Never_Sleeps.jpg.895d85bdd0fbe629ca64be398f9bf6ef.jpg

Edited by ztejas

The Signals tour is the tour I would have most liked to have seen.  Signals may be my most cherished Rush album.  I was 10 when signals came out, and to this day, it still crushes me.

Saw it as a sophomore in hs. Very cool.
10 hours ago, Rip76 said:

The Signals tour is the tour I would have most liked to have seen.  Signals may be my most cherished Rush album.  I was 10 when signals came out, and to this day, it still crushes me.

 

10 hours ago, WhatTheBuck said:

The lasers blew me away. My ears were still ringing when I went to bed that night. 

 

8 hours ago, tbone_ said:


Saw it as a sophomore in hs. Very cool.

That was my first concert in either 7th or 8th grade, Golden Earring opened and played 15 minute versions of Twilight Zone and Radar Love and not sure what else. Rush sounded exactly like the album 

Roughly 40 years after the release of the original album -- this show and the recording are spectacular.

825437044_AstralWeeks.jpg.034c097c7c189077fd8847df56a361fa.jpg

Most of my favorites have been mentioned, so I'll add this one. It's SOO good. Wish they would release it on vinyl.

 

spacer.png

12 hours ago, Rip76 said:

The Signals tour is the tour I would have most liked to have seen.  Signals may be my most cherished Rush album.  I was 10 when signals came out, and to this day, it still crushes me.

Saw them in Hartford CT on that tour:

  • The Spirit of Radio
  • Tom Sawyer
  • Freewill
  • Digital Man
  • Subdivisions
  • Vital Signs
  • The Camera Eye
  • Play Video
  • Closer to the Heart
  • Chemistry
  • The Analog Kid
  • Broon's Bane
  • The Trees
  • Red Barchetta
  • The Weapon
  • New World Man
  • Limelight
  • Countdown
  • 2112 Part I: Overture
  • 2112 Part II: The Temples of Syrinx
  • Xanadu
  • La Villa Strangiato
  • In the Mood

Encore:

  • YYZ
  • Drum Solo

Lots of talking and has some overdubs, but this one is fantastic.

 

Also lots of talking, but has some great moments, both musically and in comedy.

 

Learned about this one either here or on the Shag

 

Under_Black_Pool_Lights.jpg

 

WP-LFGA.jpg

Light Fuse, Get Away was all live performances from various shows from 1997

Live_one.jpg

Not really a fan of U2, but this is pretty awesome...given it was 1983

U2uabrs.jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.