December 19, 20214 yr Author Isabel May is good actress. Run Hide Fight was not a bad movie. Die Hard meets a school shooting. She looks like a young Faith Hill. Tim McGraw can handle himself in the action sequences. We’ll see on Faith Hill. Sam Elliott’s excellence continues. I wouldn’t try to make a Western without him.
December 20, 20214 yr Author A+++ list appearance in episode 2. My God, the favors Sheridan must have called in.
December 20, 20214 yr Watching Ep. 2 (my first) w/ the wife, who loves it. 15 mins. in it's a little slow like 90% of TV series, but the acting is good, cinematography is nice, and we'll see, fully expect it to be good. Might be the first series in awhile I get beyond 2 episodes before giving up (then I suppose I'll have to catch up on Yellowstone, as this is apparently a prequel).
December 20, 20214 yr only watched one ep tonight...but already better than Yellowstone. wagon train setup is a good storyline. also, Sam Elliott.
December 20, 20214 yr 3 hours ago, phdhorn said: Watching Ep. 2 (my first) w/ the wife, who loves it. 15 mins. in it's a little slow like 90% of TV series, but the acting is good, cinematography is nice, and we'll see, fully expect it to be good. Might be the first series in awhile I get beyond 2 episodes before giving up (then I suppose I'll have to catch up on Yellowstone, as this is apparently a prequel). The current season of Yellowstone is a steaming pile of shit. The first three are pretty entertaining, though.
December 20, 20214 yr I didn’t understand the lead-in from that four-minute thing for 1883 right in the middle of Yellowstone. Did those characters tie-in to the longer show at all? I was confused.
December 20, 20214 yr 7 hours ago, C-Man said: The current season of Yellowstone is a steaming pile of shit. The first three are pretty entertaining, though. Not to Yellowstone the 1883 thread, but there's actually a valid explanation for this. I can't go into details on here, but let's just say this is a transition/rebuilding season. Expect it to get better next season.
December 20, 20214 yr 8 hours ago, C-Man said: The current season of Yellowstone is a steaming pile of shit. The first three are pretty entertaining, though. Appreciated. I saw about 2 episodes from about season 2 and it was pretty good; acting and plot. In both of these series, I'm meh on Old West type of shit (nothing will ever, ever replace the Leone triptik in my opinion) and it's hard to avoid tired stereotypes (even in these) but the acting, props and cinematography can go a long way (I mean if you can't film beautiful landscapes out west, you suck as a camera specialist). I did catch Ep. 1 of 1883 last night after the missus went to bed, and it was pretty engaging. BBT was about as good as he's ever been in a western. His "revenge shooting" (nospoiler) scene and especially his last line after it was giggly epically good. I'll stick with 1883 for now, it's about a B+ to me, plenty good enough to keep going.
December 20, 20214 yr 19 minutes ago, phdhorn said: In both of these series, I'm meh on Old West type of shit (nothing will ever, ever replace the Leone triptik in my opinion) and it's hard to avoid tired stereotypes (even in these) but the acting, props and cinematography can go a long way (I mean if you can't film beautiful landscapes out west, you suck as a camera specialist). Taylor Sheridan is a pretty legit horseman in real life, so he actually does a pretty good job at avoiding a lot of the tired stereotypes. But yeah, even he has to include some to appeal to the masses.
December 20, 20214 yr I enjoyed the first episode, and like Yellowstone, I am thru to the end now even if the writing goes awry. One immediate question though. Why are two "Pinkerton" men leading a wagon train? That is not part of their charter.
December 20, 20214 yr My favorite thing in the series so far besides what I listed above is Tim McGraw. I said to wife, "you know what I like about Tim McGraw in this series?" and she shot right back - "he doesn't overact?" Exactly what I had in mind. He does a brilliant job of "man of few words" without being the moody, aloof quasi-hero stereotype (thanks a lot, Clint!). He seems human and even a bit unsure of his plans but presses on - very realistic Old West (I studied it), and his role is played magnificently. If he doesn't scoop up some brass for this role, it'd be a shame. He's unbelievably good. Elliott is always great but I wish his role wasn't so manic depressive, however it's not unrealistic because obviously he's had tragedy (like oh, about 96% of people in the "real" Old West). But I'll allow it. Isabel May is up and down (although some of the plot events written for her are kinda cheesy), and of course everyone you've ever seen in Old West photos are ugly and dirty, so unfortunately she and Faith Hill can't help but being hotties, but wife and I both said that through no fault of their own, they seem hard to grasp... but yeah, Hollywood and appeal and all... Anyway, it's pretty good. Hope it doesn't Fonzie the Shark out of appeal, but seems like they have a lot of big guns working on it, so there's hope!
December 20, 20214 yr 10 hours ago, mchookem said: only watched one ep tonight...but already better than Yellowstone. wagon train setup is a good storyline. also, Sam Elliott. Not a popular comment but Sam Elliot got the look and voice for sure but he’s just being same character as everything else he’s ever done before.
December 20, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, mininghorn88 said: I enjoyed the first episode, and like Yellowstone, I am thru to the end now even if the writing goes awry. One immediate question though. Why are two "Pinkerton" men leading a wagon train? That is not part of their charter. good question... as an aside, i literally cannot see anything with or any reference to Pinkertons without automatically hearing a voice in my head every time... "...besides, Jesse pays more money than you do, Mr. Pinkerton man." from my favorite western, pos rep to who can name that movie 😊
December 20, 20214 yr 2 hours ago, mchookem said: good question... as an aside, i literally cannot see anything with or any reference to Pinkertons without automatically hearing a voice in my head every time... "...besides, Jesse pays more money than you do, Mr. Pinkerton man." from my favorite western, pos rep to who can name that movie 😊 The Long Riders?
December 20, 20214 yr 2 hours ago, mchookem said: good question... as an aside, i literally cannot see anything with or any reference to Pinkertons without automatically hearing a voice in my head every time... "...besides, Jesse pays more money than you do, Mr. Pinkerton man." from my favorite western, pos rep to who can name that movie 😊 American Outlaws?
December 20, 20214 yr Do they not have snakes in Germany? And why is he telling them shumard oak is poison ivy? That seems unnecessarily cruel.
December 20, 20214 yr Old Lady: "I feel like I've been watching this since 1883 and nothing has happened."
December 20, 20214 yr This show has been done before in a vastly superior way. It’s called Lonesome Dove
December 21, 20214 yr one nitpick from the show is the preference for horses over oxen to pull the wagons. in real life on the Oregon Trail oxen were greatly preferred. not sure why they changed it here unless nobody in Hollywood knows how to wrangle oxen?
December 21, 20214 yr 9 hours ago, Horn80 said: Not a popular comment but Sam Elliot got the look and voice for sure but he’s just being same character as everything else he’s ever done before. I agree. ETA I agree it's an unpopular comment. Sam Elliot is a goddamn national treasure, you Communist. Edited December 21, 20214 yr by Parliament
December 21, 20214 yr 21 minutes ago, Parliament said: I agree. ETA I agree it's an unpopular comment. Sam Elliot is a goddamn national treasure, you Communist. Correct. This is correct
December 21, 20214 yr 33 minutes ago, Parliament said: I agree. ETA I agree it's an unpopular comment. Sam Elliot is a goddamn national treasure, you Communist.
December 21, 20214 yr 3 hours ago, TonyTexas said: This show has been done before in a vastly superior way. It’s called Lonesome Dove There's a difference between a bunch of cowhands jerking it in the saddle on a trail drive and a wagon train.
December 21, 20214 yr 3 hours ago, TonyTexas said: This show has been done before in a vastly superior way. It’s called Lonesome Dove You tend your biscuits.
December 21, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, WithoutAClue said: one nitpick from the show is the preference for horses over oxen to pull the wagons. in real life on the Oregon Trail oxen were greatly preferred. not sure why they changed it here unless nobody in Hollywood knows how to wrangle oxen? There was a scene in Ep. 1 where Sam Elliott was chastising the Germans for wanting oxen instead of horses and that "oxes [sic] will never make it." In reality, horses almost never pulled wagons as you said. Oxen were more durable, grazed easier on the natural grasses of the plains (horses required grains as well, heavy and relatively expensive), you could use oxen to pull plows once you got there, and Indians were more likely to steal horses and leave the oxen alone. Plus oxen were a lot cheaper, stronger, and you could eat 'em at their end. Not sure if there is some unique reason for that screenwriting, but normally that would be bogus. But Brennan's reasons in that little scene were completely wrong per the usual requirements, especially where he said that oxen couldn't make it (but horses could?). Oxen were much stronger and tougher. Only reason I could think was that horses were faster and could get there sooner - if it was a shorter distance. But they don't really know when they're going to stop, so that's out.
December 21, 20214 yr To anyone questioning anything Sam Elliott does: Edited December 21, 20214 yr by HornOnTheBayou
December 21, 20214 yr Its always fun to remember that everyone in Fort Worth's great grandmother was a whore
December 21, 20214 yr When I clicked on the thread I was expecting to have a discussion about the 1883 eruption of Krakatoa in Indonesia. I'm sad that I don't think this is what it is about.
December 21, 20214 yr Isabel May reminds me of Jennifer Lawrence, maybe a little Rosamund Pike. Her southern accent is trash though, awful choice for narrator. Tim McGraw is surprisingly good so far. Liking this better than the shit Yellowstone is boring me with. Edited December 21, 20214 yr by Revolution512
December 21, 20214 yr On 12/19/2021 at 8:11 PM, billfromlaketravis said: A+++ list appearance in episode 2. My God, the favors Sheridan must have called in. was that Hanks as the Union officer comforting Dutton in the opening scene?
December 21, 20214 yr 1 minute ago, mchookem said: was that Hanks as the Union officer comforting Dutton in the opening scene? Yep
December 21, 20214 yr Author 8 minutes ago, mchookem said: was that Hanks as the Union officer comforting Dutton in the opening scene? Yep
December 21, 20214 yr 6 hours ago, TonyTexas said: This show has been done before in a vastly superior way. It’s called Lonesome Dove Before that it was called Wagon Train.
December 21, 20214 yr Episode 2 random thoughts. Not really spoilers. 1. I seriously doubt any Texas cowboy would be wearing wooley chaps, even in April. 2. Tim McGraw's beard growth rate must be highly variable. 3. He sucks at using a shovel. Probably why the South lost the war.
December 21, 20214 yr 11 hours ago, phdhorn said: There was a scene in Ep. 1 where Sam Elliott was chastising the Germans for wanting oxen instead of horses and that "oxes [sic] will never make it." In reality, horses almost never pulled wagons as you said. Oxen were more durable, grazed easier on the natural grasses of the plains (horses required grains as well, heavy and relatively expensive), you could use oxen to pull plows once you got there, and Indians were more likely to steal horses and leave the oxen alone. Plus oxen were a lot cheaper, stronger, and you could eat 'em at their end. Not sure if there is some unique reason for that screenwriting, but normally that would be bogus. But Brennan's reasons in that little scene were completely wrong per the usual requirements, especially where he said that oxen couldn't make it (but horses could?). Oxen were much stronger and tougher. Only reason I could think was that horses were faster and could get there sooner - if it was a shorter distance. But they don't really know when they're going to stop, so that's out. Recently rewatched the miniseries Centennial and they had the same scene regarding Oxen and going over the mountains to Oregon. Looks like Sheridan just likes to steal shit from old movies and shows.
December 21, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, 66BUFF said: Recently rewatched the miniseries Centennial and they had the same scene regarding Oxen and going over the mountains to Oregon. Looks like Sheridan just likes to steal shit from old movies and shows. Or maybe, stick with me here, it was a real thing.
December 21, 20214 yr 13 hours ago, phdhorn said: There was a scene in Ep. 1 where Sam Elliott was chastising the Germans for wanting oxen instead of horses and that "oxes [sic] will never make it." In reality, horses almost never pulled wagons as you said. Oxen were more durable, grazed easier on the natural grasses of the plains (horses required grains as well, heavy and relatively expensive), you could use oxen to pull plows once you got there, and Indians were more likely to steal horses and leave the oxen alone. Plus oxen were a lot cheaper, stronger, and you could eat 'em at their end. Not sure if there is some unique reason for that screenwriting, but normally that would be bogus. But Brennan's reasons in that little scene were completely wrong per the usual requirements, especially where he said that oxen couldn't make it (but horses could?). Oxen were much stronger and tougher. Only reason I could think was that horses were faster and could get there sooner - if it was a shorter distance. But they don't really know when they're going to stop, so that's out. Yep Oxen > Mules > Horses
December 22, 20214 yr 12 hours ago, 66BUFF said: Recently rewatched the miniseries Centennial and they had the same scene regarding Oxen and going over the mountains to Oregon. Looks like Sheridan just likes to steal shit from old movies and shows. There is nothing "mini" about Centennial - it was damn near 24 hours long. Centennial was an amazing production for its era. That cast alone...
December 22, 20214 yr Isabel May reminds me of Jennifer Lawrence, maybe a little Rosamund Pike. Her southern accent is trash though, awful choice for narrator. Tim McGraw is surprisingly good so far. Liking this better than the shit Yellowstone is boring me with.Isabel is quite attractive. Got a little Florence Pugh thing going too. Faith Hill looks weird.
December 22, 20214 yr 1 hour ago, Buzzrock said: Isabel is quite attractive. True, but someone that skinny will never survive in rural America. First threshing season and she'll waste away and die.
December 22, 20214 yr 2 hours ago, Buzzrock said: Faith Hill looks weird. Very. Wife and I couldn't figure out what she had done to her face.
December 22, 20214 yr Am I the only one strangely attracted to the bitch in all black ? Haven’t gotten a great look at her face but I dig a raven haired woman. She needs to let her hair down, and you know there’s a merry widow ensemble’ under that dress.
December 22, 20214 yr 43 minutes ago, Onboard 2.0 said: Am I the only one strangely attracted to the bitch in all black ? We need to talk...
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.