Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

1 hour ago, Nivek said:

Are they really useless? Or are they just biding time and looking for any excuse not to act because they know they are still too weak at this point to put up much of a fight.   This would be like Chamberlain hearing about the Nazi Nuke program while reading a report about the readiness of the UK forces.  

 

Yeah, I thought it was really well done and felt "real." They'd have to be terrified of ISB traps at that point and people in that position would HAVE to wonder about the authenticity of the information. They still made the right call in the end without really wasting much time.

  • Replies 2.4k
  • Views 167.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

Posted Images

Weirdly, I’ve seen some that have watched R1 post Andor and the two projects not fully clicking with them. I guess it can be difficult for some after watching Andor be the main guy for 2 seasons and then in his final chapter in R1 he’s taking a step back. 

5 hours ago, jeevsie said:

A single "May the Force be With You" works so much better because of that.

I actually wished they didn't add that line. I know they need it for continuity with R1 and subsequent chapters, but it felt forced.

 

9 minutes ago, Superhero said:

I actually wished they didn't add that line. I know they need it for continuity with R1 and subsequent chapters, but it felt forced.

 

Eh is came from Bail, the character in this story most connected to the notion of that statement given his history with Obi Wan and the fact that he is raising the daughter of a fallen Jedi.  It was fine given all that background. 

Edited by Surly Bevo

  • Author

My definitive list of the best Star Wars characters:

1 Luthen
2 Kleya
3 Mon
4 Han
5 Cassian
6 K2SO
7 Saw
8 Vader
9 Luke
10 Porkins

9 minutes ago, CooterBrown said:

My definitive list of the best Star Wars characters:

1 Luthen
2 Kleya
3 Mon
4 Han
5 Cassian
6 K2SO
7 Saw
8 Vader
9 Luke
10 Porkins

  1. B2EMO
  2. Captain Rex
  3. Obi Wan
30 minutes ago, Superhero said:

I actually wished they didn't add that line. I know they need it for continuity with R1 and subsequent chapters, but it felt forced.

 

 

1 minute ago, Michael Knight said:

B2EMO

I’m so happy for him 

2 minutes ago, Michael Knight said:

image.thumb.png.8ee80d6300c1dff5252b8e6ccb6d8fc6.png

That's what she used to do to Syril with the lights off.....

13 minutes ago, Js1 said:

I’m so happy for him 

He had a robot friend to play with.


The force line didn't bother me. It's in keeping with the OT. General Dodonna says it to the pilots before the Battle of Yavin. I feel like it was something said to people who remembered the time when the Jedi were the keepers of the peace. If anything, George polluted that with the prequels. Even Tarken tells Vader you are all that is left of that religion. 

 

Dedra's ending reminded me of the Colonel from Boogie Nights. Shut up, Dedra!

Edited by mdmost

3 minutes ago, Michael Knight said:

image.thumb.png.8ee80d6300c1dff5252b8e6ccb6d8fc6.png

Her facial expressions this whole scene were amazing

And her absolute disgust when Heert approached her for advice/help. 

45 minutes ago, Js1 said:

Her facial expressions this whole scene were amazing

And her absolute disgust when Heert approached her for advice/help. 

And yet she still helped him out.  It was so fitting for her character, in that even as she was realizing the system had no more use for her and would destroy her, she couldn't help but still want it to prevail.  

5 hours ago, Rimbo said:

I didn't immediately rewatch any of these scenes, except for Krennic v Partagaz, and it was entirely to watch Anton Lesser's performance.

Now here's a guy (/Collinsworth) in Partagaz who keeps the Empire going. He's efficient, no-nonsense, competent, and deals with a room full of backstabbing ambitious sycophants amazingly without ever raising his voice.

And here he is, raising his voice just once before bringing himself back under control. Finally panicking because he knows he's done for, if not the entire ISB.

 

16 hours ago, AUS-97HORN said:

Dedra got done sooooo fucking dirty. 

Krennick pushing her down with his finger was a got damn moment. Up until that point and later in R1 (until the end), he was directing the violence, not doing it himself.

 

3 hours ago, MissingInAction said:

Her seamless movement through the hospital laying waste and capping motherfuckers without breaking stride like a fucking ninja.

We didn't see her laying the charges. I like how it went from Luthen pressing the trigger button Naboo (?), and her pressing the trigger to blow up the shuttles.

 

1 hour ago, Js1 said:

I’m so happy for him 

Yup. The joy in his v-v-v-voice was real.

3 hours ago, wildcat09 said:

Yeah, I thought it was really well done and felt "real." They'd have to be terrified of ISB traps at that point and people in that position would HAVE to wonder about the authenticity of the information. They still made the right call in the end without really wasting much time.

I think they were spooked for good reason. 

So the two senators had an interaction with a spy/assassin with one being the target.   

Mon was under constant surveillance and having multiple spies as drivers/security for her.   

Draven was still in the process of turning the militia into an army, but he no doubt heard about the imperial spies caught and killed (Will was there)    

So the members of the leadership group all had recent interactions and stories of espionage, while knowing that their espionage wing under Luthen collapsed, with some of the remnant members being undisciplined and still operating like freelance agents.   A lot of time had passed since the heist, as they are procuring ships and x-wings they probably overlooked the importance of those initial funds.   But I think Cassian taking the cue from Draven to not attack the other member who questioned him/Luthan also signified a change in their relationship and trust.   I think Draven likely vouched for him, Mon, did so as well, and Organa was reminded what Cassian did and the costs he paid.  I think that is why Bail told him. 

I also like how the force sensitive healer stared Cassian down with a disturbed look.  I think she sensed his fate in that moment. 

 

Cassian and Jyn Erso should have heisted an Imperial shuttle craft when they got out of the tower and booked it instead of holding each other on the beach (even more so now that we know Cassian just orphaned his kid and Bix is going to have to work at space hooters).

I admit I didn't have Partagaz dying on my list.

I also didn't expect Bix, Dedra, nor Kleya surviving.

I really liked (?) Supervisor Lagret's subtle gesture to the guards not to go in after Partegaz shot himself.

 

 

Edited by Superhero

3 minutes ago, Superhero said:

I really liked (?) Supervisor Lagret's subtle gesture to the guards not to go in after Partegaz shot himself.

 

 

oh yeah, there was some interview with Gilroy yesterday where he pointed out how great Michael Jenn's acting was in that scene

Was really hoping to see Kino Loy again as Dedra's shift supervisor 🤣

4 hours ago, CooterBrown said:

My definitive list of the best Star Wars characters:

1 Luthen
2 Kleya
3 Mon
4 Han
5 Cassian
6 K2SO
7 Saw
8 Vader
9 Luke
10 Porkins

Dedra, Partagaz and the Grand Inquisitor from the Obi Wan series belong in this list. Partagaz ending his own life after realizing he failed to contain the Rebellion was incredibly acted.

1 minute ago, speed817 said:

Was really hoping to see Kino Loy again as Dedra's shift supervisor 🤣

Would have been nice to see but Gilroy said Loy’s end of season 1 moment was too perfect to bring him back

In my head canon, Kino Loy went out like a boss after the Empire came to reinforce the prison. He wasn't going back in. 

26 minutes ago, Macklemore said:

Dedra, Partagaz and the Grand Inquisitor from the Obi Wan series belong in this list. Partagaz ending his own life after realizing he failed to contain the Rebellion was incredibly acted.

Partagaz had the best lines in the show.

Now I want to go back and watch every episode so I can write them down and quote them to my minions when they get out of line.

3 hours ago, wildcat09 said:

And yet she still helped him out.  It was so fitting for her character, in that even as she was realizing the system had no more use for her and would destroy her, she couldn't help but still want it to prevail.  

She’s a true believer. She was so aghast that anyone would accuse her of being a rebel spy.

Krennick was right though. In another life, she would have been a very good one.  She was just so ambitious and wholly focused on Axis that it was eventually her downfall.

Had she just stayed in her lane or found other ways to undermine Heert’s investigation into Axis, instead of an unauthorized raid and arrest, she would probably have risen quite high

Edited by Js1

Just finished.  I thought it was great.

2 questions:

1. I understand the rebellion has to be cynical to survive; but how many fucking deposits in the Good Guys Bank & Trust does fucking Cassian have to make before the leaders trust him? That inquiry in E12 was like he was just some random shmuck walking in from the rain.  " Maybe I should stop saving people" was the line of the show, IMHO.

2. Why are there multiple abodes in the series that just leave their front door, if there was one,  wide ass open, with zero regard to AC or insects in a tropical environment? Meanwhile on Dagobah...

 

Edited by Iceman

I think everyone is paranoid of being found out or failing into a trap. They also didn't trust Luthen and thought he could've been compromised. It's also the same two people in Rogue One who didn't want to attack the base on Scariff because they were scared.

Gq6xmkIWUAIKah6?format=jpg

6 hours ago, CooterBrown said:

My definitive list of the best Star Wars characters:

1 Luthen
2 Kleya
3 Mon
4 Han
5 Cassian
6 K2SO
7 Saw
8 Vader
9 Luke
10 Porkins

No love for C1-10P?

29 minutes ago, mdmost said:

I think everyone is paranoid of being found out or failing into a trap. They also didn't trust Luthen and thought he could've been compromised. It's also the same two people in Rogue One who didn't want to attack the base on Scariff because they were scared.

Gq6xmkIWUAIKah6?format=jpg

Imperialism, capitalism; tomato, tomahto.

No CR.

39 minutes ago, Iceman said:

1. I understand the rebellion has to be cynical to survive; but how many fucking deposits in the Good Guys Bank & Trust does fucking Cassian have to make before the leaders trust him? That inquiry in E12 was like he was just some random shmuck walking in from the rain.  " Maybe I should stop saving people" was the line of the show, IMHO.

Super Troopers Yes GIF by Searchlight Pictures

Not seeing Max Rebo, the leader of the Max Rebo Band, on anyone’s favorite character list is shocking. Max, along with Sy Snootles and Droopy McCool, brought down the house wherever they perform.

return of the jedi episode 6 GIF by Star Wars

7 minutes ago, Levi said:

Not seeing Max Rebo, the leader of the Max Rebo Band, on anyone’s favorite character list is shocking. Max, along with Sy Snootles and Droopy McCool, brought down the house wherever they perform.

return of the jedi episode 6 GIF by Star Wars

It’s Neel erasure for me 

ok now hear me out

Marvin the Paranoid Android and B2EMO in a buddy movie

Directed by Tim Burton

"I think you should know I'm feeling very depressed."

"S-s-s-so am I."

Edited by Rimbo

10 minutes ago, The Dog said:

IMG_3475.thumb.png.418bec90513028fc703c09b5e8be0a91.png

Everything she did is so much more impressive considering she had 7 credits to her name prior to Andor. 2 shorts, 10 TV episodes and a voice credit in Wicked

On episode 5. 
 

bix kinda ass. I know she been through it mentally. But she lookin busted and not fun 

for some reason syril grew on me. Season one first few episodes I didn’t like his up tight ass tracking down our main man. 
 

but he pulled a high ranking baddie. And that commendable. He low key funny too. 
 

I like him. 

Bix named the baby Din Djarin, and when their planet was attacked he was rescued by the Mandalorians 

28 minutes ago, Js1 said:

Everything she did is so much more impressive considering she had 7 credits to her name prior to Andor. 2 shorts, 10 TV episodes and a voice credit in Wicked

Her agent needs to get to work.

5 minutes ago, Bill Brasky said:

Bix named the baby Din Djarin, and when their planet was attacked he was rescued by the Mandalorians 

IMG_3159.thumb.jpeg.69d0b7b79fac1e4c7ed738e33cbf3ca0.jpeg

  • Popular Post

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-features/andor-elizabeth-dulau-kleya-finale-1236216087/
 

Quote

“My agent said, ‘The only note [from your Andorcallback] was you seemed a little bit nervous. So they want to see you again. Walk in that room with as much confidence as you can; walk in that room like you are the dog’s bollocks,’” Dulau tells THR, quoting her rep’s words. “Then she said, ‘Also, you’ll be reading at Pinewood Studios opposite Stellan Skarsgård, but don’t let that make you nervous.’ I think I just burst out laughing because that’s insane. It was just an unbelievable thing to hear.”

 

4 hours ago, Murfdogg21 said:

Cassian and Jyn Erso should have heisted an Imperial shuttle craft when they got out of the tower and booked it instead of holding each other on the beach (even more so now that we know Cassian just orphaned his kid and Bix is going to have to work at space hooters).

Yep Cassian takes Jyn back with him to Bix and his whole scene becomes a warlock party.

So here is a question that it wasn't Andor's job to answer, but I don't know if it has been answered definitely anywhere else in the Star Wars universe.  What is the foundation of the relationship between Saw Gerrera and the Urso family?

I just re-watched 10, 11 and 12.  This was off the charts good storytelling.  Next week I am starting a re-watch from Season 1 and the through Rogue 1.  I wouldn't mind a Klaya and Wilmon story line.  Maybe they help the Bothans get the info they need for the 2nd Death Star.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.