December 23, 20232 yr Author If we keep it to 2 non-solo, non-super group, I think Kim Deal (Pixies and Breeders) and Dave Mustaine (Metalica and Megadeath) fit the bill. I think 3 is just too exclusive a group.
December 23, 20232 yr So Sammy Hagar? I think being there at the start is a key differentiating factor, also.- with regard to this discussion. Edited December 23, 20232 yr by slorch
December 23, 20232 yr Author 3 minutes ago, slorch said: So Sammy Hagar? I think being there at the start is a key differentiating factor, also.- with regard to this discussion. Yeah, I think being a founder is an important factor. We could also include bands that sprang out of other bands, like Joy Division to New Order, and Bauhaus to Love and Rockets.
December 23, 20232 yr I don't want to start a thread about supergroups, so riddle me this: Is Traveling Wilburys the biggest supergroup of all time? I mean, what band could possibly top it? Dylan, a Beatle, Orbison and Petty? Yowza. I didn't even like them all that much.
December 23, 20232 yr 3 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: I don't want to start a thread about supergroups, so riddle me this: Is Traveling Wilburys the biggest supergroup of all time? I mean, what band could possibly top it? Dylan, a Beatle, Orbison and Petty? Yowza. I didn't even like them all that much. And Jeff Lynne. You're right.
December 23, 20232 yr Author 8 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: I don't want to start a thread about supergroups, so riddle me this: Is Traveling Wilburys the biggest supergroup of all time? I mean, what band could possibly top it? Dylan, a Beatle, Orbison and Petty? Yowza. I didn't even like them all that much. The Highwaymen would be a contender too
December 23, 20232 yr Just now, DixonHur said: The Highwaymen would be a contender too Damn good call. 5 minutes ago, ajax said: And Jeff Lynne. You're right. I am so not a fan of Jeff Lynne. Honestly, I thought he was mostly their producer, but I guess he was in the band.
December 23, 20232 yr 19 hours ago, jimmyjazz said: OK, top this one: Tanya Donelly. Throwing Muses, The Breeders, and Belly. (No, I don't know sales.) She's no Kristin Hersh, tho
December 26, 20231 yr On 12/23/2023 at 4:15 PM, DixonHur said: The Highwaymen would be a contender too And the Rat Pack.
December 28, 20231 yr I could argue Bob Dylan, simply as he has created and fronted so many bands it's literally mind blowing. But since he was always the front man except for Traveling Wilburys, you guys may not think it counts. Yet I could point at his move from a folks band to an electric guitar band as perhaps the single seminal moment of change in the history of modern music. But I understand if you completely disagree with my premise. 😉
December 28, 20231 yr On 12/22/2023 at 8:48 PM, Celery Man said: if the game is "dudes who have been in lots of successful bands" than we shouldn't be this far in without at least a mention of Grohl obviously Nirvana, Foo Fighters. Tenacious D. Them Crooked Vultures. I think he was in Queens of the Stone Age? Yeah, Grohl absolutely has to be in this conversation. He was in Queens. Played all the drums on their biggest album.
December 28, 20231 yr On 12/22/2023 at 8:17 PM, jimmyjazz said: Zappa? I mean, he sure dragged a long litany of "randos" (geniuses) into the spotlight. I was trying to figure Steely Dan (which included Skunk Baxter who founded Doobie Brothers), Eagles, Poco, the list goes on, but it's hard to get past "2". Once you're famous, your next new group is probably a supergroup. Along the lines of Zappa would be Robert Fripp. King Crimson has been about 12 different bands over 50 years. those prog rock groups of the 70s were always very incestuous. Greg Lake was on KC first album and there for Emerson, Lake & Palmer (which probably falls into the supergroup category). Bill Bruford drummed for Yes, KC, Genesis and had a solo career, etc…. Edited December 28, 20231 yr by Goredho
December 28, 20231 yr Eddie Van Halen - Van Halen, Van Halen and Van Halen. I'm kidding. But only slightly.
December 28, 20231 yr Todd Snider, Todd Snider and the wrecks, Hard Working Americans, Elmo Buzz and the Eastside Bulldog (and rythmn guitar player for KK Ryder) Edited December 28, 20231 yr by Litig8r
December 28, 20231 yr Yeah, Grohl absolutely has to be in this conversation. He was in Queens. Played all the drums on their biggest album.Was he officially in the band? He also played most of the drums on NIN’s With Teeth but he wasn’t in the band.
December 28, 20231 yr Was he officially in the band? He also played most of the drums on NIN’s With Teeth but he wasn’t in the band. He was in Queens. Toured and everything IIRC. It was never intended to be permanent though, but that’s always kinda been Homme’s MO
December 29, 20231 yr On 12/22/2023 at 7:11 PM, DixonHur said: I was listening to Yazoo (or Yaz for us Americans) today and it got me thinking about people who have had the most successful careers in music. Not total records sold, but most successful bands started by one person. Vince Clarke was a founding member of Depeche Mode, Yazoo, and Erasure. I can think of several artists who have been founding members of 2 successful bands, but who else has had Platinum records as a founding member of 3 or more bands? Damon Albarn - Blur (platinum), Gorillaz (platinum), The Good, The Bad and the Queen (Gold), solo + tons of collaborations. Close enough to your criteria I hope. Who doesn't want to collaborate with Damon?
December 29, 20231 yr Unrelated but related, “the news” (do you like Huey Lewis and the News?) were the studio band for Elvis Costello’s “My Aim is True”
December 29, 20231 yr Actually maybe that backing band is just a funny flip to this - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clover_(band) Clover was an American country rock band formed in Mill Valley, California and active from 1967 to 1978.[1] Clover are best known as the backing band for Elvis Costello's 1977 debut album My Aim Is True (recorded in the UK), and for its members going on to greater success with Huey Lewis and the News, the Doobie Brothers, and Lucinda Williams.
December 29, 20231 yr One other adjacent topic thought is that George Harrison has to be the greatest non-primary songwriter in a band that is the primary thing all of its members are famous for. By a big margin, right? also, Lou Barlow - Dinosaur Jr, Folk Implosion, Sebadoh Edited December 29, 20231 yr by Celery Man
December 29, 20231 yr 31 minutes ago, Celery Man said: One other adjacent topic thought is that George Harrison has to be the greatest non-primary songwriter in a band that is the primary thing all of its members are famous for. By a big margin, right? George Harrison was my first thought. And the Beatles might not have recorded many of his songs, but IMO, I like his solo stuff a lot more than any other Beatle and Beatle material was generally by favorite songs. Beatles songs: Here Comes The Son, Something, While My Guitar Gently Weeps, Solo career on these three alone: Beware of Darkness, What Is Life, Give Me Love And yep. Wilburys for greatest supergroup. They wrote all new songs among themselves. And on that first record, not a bump in the road. Highway Men did older songs of their solo career and covers.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.