December 28, 2024Dec 28 holy fuck, this guy is 73 and he looks like he's 100. Ringo looks like a teenager next to this asshole.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 I'm 10 minutes into this ego project of his kid's, and I'm waiting for Phil to talk about how he had an onion on his belt, which was the fashion of the day.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 Jeez, what's with all the shit talk about Phil? He's a legit legend on the kit.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 7 hours ago, Gil Bang said: is he really? Watch the doc and listen to all the drummers rave about him.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 1 hour ago, jimmyjazz said: Watch the doc and listen to all the drummers rave about him. They just don't want that goblin coming after them.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 Have you ever watched something and then wished that you hadn't. Everybody gets old and everyone dies, but it's sad and depressing to see people that shaped my world get to the end of the road. I caught a 10 minutes segment of this where they set up his old kit and he got behind it for the first time in years. He was so frail that he could only pick up one stick and lightly tap a few drums. He'e only 73. On one hand he shouldn't look that old, on the other hand, that's what a lot of 73 year olds look like. .
December 28, 2024Dec 28 Popular Post 2 hours ago, 0xdeadbeef said: Have you ever watched something and then wished that you hadn't. Yes, and I watched it in person.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 Author 2 hours ago, 0xdeadbeef said: Have you ever watched something and then wished that you hadn't. Everybody gets old and everyone dies, but it's sad and depressing to see people that shaped my world get to the end of the road. I caught a 10 minutes segment of this where they set up his old kit and he got behind it for the first time in years. He was so frail that he could only pick up one stick and lightly tap a few drums. He'e only 73. On one hand he shouldn't look that old, on the other hand, that's what a lot of 73 year olds look like. . Same it’s kind of sad. I don’t know much about him as a person although apparently he’s got a reputation. But 80s Phil Collins was the soundtrack of my youth.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 21 minutes ago, HiggyBaby said: Same it’s kind of sad. I don’t know much about him as a person although apparently he’s got a reputation. It turns out he's a huge collector of Alamo artifacts, and he's donated quite a bit of it to the state.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 You guys have me curious. What's with all the Phil Collins hate. Did I miss something or is my sarcasm meter off?
December 28, 2024Dec 28 2 hours ago, Bill Brasky said: You guys have me curious. What's with all the Phil Collins hate. Did I miss something or is my sarcasm meter off? Only thing I remember was he did that song about homelessness, and then a bunch of homeless people parked in the yard of his mansion and he had to evict them. Which was a bad look, but what ya gonna do? And he made Genesis from an arty band into something more popular. But again, is that bad? And then he had a great solo career with the kind of hit parade most artists could only dream of. Smells like jealousy more than anything. Dunno any other reasons, I've never been THAT interested.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 1 hour ago, Rip76 said: Tommy Shaw type thing? Leland Sklar FTW 18 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: What's the Tommy Shaw reference about?
December 28, 2024Dec 28 4 hours ago, Bill Brasky said: You guys have me curious. What's with all the Phil Collins hate. Did I miss something or is my sarcasm meter off? There was that one time where someone was drowning and he wouldn't lend a had. That's a pretty dick move.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 36 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: What's the Tommy Shaw reference about? From HF's. Someone had a story about taking a chic to a show and she went home with Tommy Shaw. (Or something like that) I was wondering if Phil "Shaw'd," Gil's date or something.
December 28, 2024Dec 28 He is an honorary Texan. Had a huge collection of Alamo stuff and donated it to the state. Cut him some slack!
December 29, 2024Dec 29 I'm actually not even a little bit surprised to see Surly talk shit on Phil Collins.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 17 minutes ago, Okie State said: I'm actually not even a little bit surprised to see Surly talk shit on Phil Collins. Well. Just the one guy.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 8 hours ago, jimmyjazz said: It turns out he's a huge collector of Alamo artifacts, and he's donated quite a bit of it to the state. He believed he fought in the Battle of the Alamo for the good guys and was reincarnated according to a Texas Monthly article years ago. He also replaced Peter Gabriel as a lead singer and could play the drums like a beast simultaneously and pull all kinds of hot ass in his prime. But he was no Gil Bang, mind you
December 29, 2024Dec 29 I mean, the same guy invalidated all future opinions when he shat on Pet Sounds years ago. I thought everyone was on the same page that he is a know-nothing shit take factory.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 Well, I don't particularly like The Beach Boys or Pet Sounds, but that aside, Phil Collins is far from a know-nothing. To each his own, I suppose.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 4 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: Well, I don't particularly like The Beach Boys or Pet Sounds That tracks. It's no Boston, that's for sure.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 5 minutes ago, G650 said: That tracks. It's no Boston, that's for sure. Definitely. In my defense, I do recognize that Brian Wilson was in pretty rarified air. It just isn't for me.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 1 hour ago, jimmyjazz said: Well, I don't particularly like The Beach Boys or Pet Sounds, but that aside, Phil Collins is far from a know-nothing. To each his own, I suppose. I am a Phil Collins fan. I was just remembering that the guy shit talking Collins has a history of dumb music takes.
December 29, 2024Dec 29 10 minutes ago, Chips O'Toole said: I am a Phil Collins fan. I was just remembering that the guy shit talking Collins has a history of dumb music takes. Sorry, I misunderstood who you were referring to.
December 30, 2024Dec 30 On 12/28/2024 at 3:09 PM, Rimbo said: And he made Genesis from an arty band into something more popular. But again, is that bad? And then he had a great solo career with the kind of hit parade most artists could only dream of. Smells like jealousy more than anything. Dunno any other reasons, I've never been THAT interested. Yeah, like the guys that used to be in Genesis with him Edited December 30, 2024Dec 30 by Dennis Taylor
December 30, 2024Dec 30 Phil is great. He’s more Ringo than Peart, but that’s ok. That dude put out some damn good music and some of the best musicians in the world waited for his call.
August 9Aug 9 This obviously isn’t new, but someone tweeted he was dressed like an IT tech. Don’t care, dude can ball.
August 9Aug 9 On 12/28/2024 at 2:09 PM, Rimbo said: And he made Genesis from an arty band into something more popular. But again, is that bad? Missed this back in December. Yeah, it's bad (just imo). But that's ok. Peter Gabriel's solo career was really what a continued arty Genesis would have been.
August 9Aug 9 21 minutes ago, Goredho said: Missed this back in December. Yeah, it's bad (just imo). But that's ok. Peter Gabriel's solo career was really what a continued arty Genesis would have been. But even Gabriel went much more mainstream in the mid-80s with “So”.
August 9Aug 9 1 hour ago, Goredho said: Missed this back in December. Yeah, it's bad (just imo). But that's ok. Peter Gabriel's solo career was really what a continued arty Genesis would have been. I think "ABACAB" is one of the great pop-rock albums of that era. It sounds fucking fantastic, and I give Phil Collins most of that credit.
August 9Aug 9 Both Genesis and Peter Gabriel did waaay better separate than they did together. Mike Rutherford was the only one that was equivalent in and out of the band.
August 9Aug 9 51 minutes ago, jimmyjazz said: I think "ABACAB" is one of the great pop-rock albums of that era. It sounds fucking fantastic, and I give Phil Collins most of that credit. That's cool. Yeah, I mean, it's nothing against Phil Collins, really. PG left, Collins stepped up, and they became something different. I just didn't like the band's output much after they had become much more conventional/radio/video friendly. And by the time they had gotten to "Invisible Touch", they had lost me.
August 9Aug 9 14 minutes ago, Goredho said: That's cool. Yeah, I mean, it's nothing against Phil Collins, really. PG left, Collins stepped up, and they became something different. I just didn't like the band's output much after they had become much more conventional/radio/video friendly. And by the time they had gotten to "Invisible Touch", they had lost me. That's more or less when they found me. "The Brazilian" remains one of my favorite instrumentals.
August 9Aug 9 2 hours ago, sasquatch69 said: But even Gabriel went much more mainstream in the mid-80s with “So”. Yeah, everything that was "progressive rock" from the 70s did. Genesis became what they became, Yes had "Owner of a Lonely Heart", etc... But, to me, while PG obviously embraced mainstream songwriting to have charting singles like Solsbury Hill and Sledgehammer (great songs), he also had a whole lot of less mainstream stuff on those albums, too. Intruder, Biko, Rhythm of the Heat, San Jacinto, etc... were really creative, interesting and different from so much of what was being pushed on radio and MTV. I think he did a great job straddling the fence. 1 minute ago, Rimbo said: That's more or less when they found me. "The Brazilian" remains one of my favorite instrumentals. Yeah, they certainly found a lot more people in the 80s than they did the 70s.
August 9Aug 9 to be fair, my age didn't hit double digits until the 80s; prog rock was not exactly on my radar then
August 9Aug 9 I'll preface this by emphasizing I'm someone who listens to Gentle Giant, Wishbone Ash and the like, the problem with early Genesis and Peter Gabriel is the shit was just half baked. They got a lot better at what they did later. It wasn't really commercial vs non commercial.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.