Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Thoughts on time and temp for a smaller brisket (4.5 lbs)?  Wife comes home from Bristol Farms all excited that she got a brisket on sale for $11/lb.   Me:
230114_908223010.jpg
Anyway, trimmed and ready, but I prefer a long slow cook.  If I toss it on tonight at 225 (electric smoker so temp will stay consistent- deal with it), is 18 hours too long?  
 
21104472b66bc199bec4707002c4ef7e.jpg
8 hours MAX, prob more like 6 or 7. Got a temp probe? Just keep an eye on it starting at around hour 5 and start tender probe testing around 190 or so.
  • Replies 3.4k
  • Views 297.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Brisket, potato salad (recipe from Franklin’s book is a good one), pintos, blueberry cobbler. This one turned out very good; WSM ran like a champ as always.

  • solamente73
    solamente73

    19.31lbs before trimming.  Costco Prime.  Really liked the shape.  Nice, thick flat.  Oak lump with hickory chunks.  About 18 hours at 235*.  No wrap.  Flavor was exceptional - that was one tasty cow.

  • Brisket prices are down again. Found this 9.5# prime brisket at Costco for $2.69/lb. 2:1 pepper to salt ratio, smoked on my BGE for about 6.5 hours at 275*. Wrapped in butcher paper and rested for 1

Posted Images

Damn, @Dr Fear with the triple post for emphasis!

Yes, I have a probe.  I'll start it first thing in the am.  Go maybe 8-10 hrs.  

Using the 1.5 hrs per pound est, it’s probably less than 7 hours. I’d also guess it’s the flat without much fat, so the stall may be brief. I’d be watching as early as 5 hours in

Forgot to post these from last week, got a raw brisket from a local place that was selling extras (Heim in Fort Worth), I did a horrible job of managing the fire overnight and the flat suffered.

ac19e38d767c022e00147966d3c28dc7.jpga3fca39e9dff8fe17cb7273adcb395c0.jpga9514dd8ba0312a13f48ffa0a600eec7.jpg2313e6700795bd0cdf6345121b9a5883.jpg46bec075758876e1ddc6891301f73708.jpg

3 minutes ago, luke duke said:

 


Please fire your interior decorator.

 

That yellow tile in the kitchen is easily the worst thing inside the house when we bought it a few years ago, but I'm really not keen on spending thousands of dollars on a new countertop.

4 hours ago, Dr Fear said:
4 hours ago, Sbbruin said:
Thoughts on time and temp for a smaller brisket (4.5 lbs)?  Wife comes home from Bristol Farms all excited that she got a brisket on sale for $11/lb.   Me:
230114_908223010.jpg
Anyway, trimmed and ready, but I prefer a long slow cook.  If I toss it on tonight at 225 (electric smoker so temp will stay consistent- deal with it), is 18 hours too long?  
 
21104472b66bc199bec4707002c4ef7e.jpg

Read more  

8 hours MAX, prob more like 6 or 7. Got a temp probe? Just keep an eye on it starting at around hour 5 and start tender probe testing around 190 or so.

Got to agree on the 6-7 hours max and watch closely from hour 5 on.  18 hrs will ruin it unless you like really funky jerky.

4 hours ago, Sbbruin said:

Damn, @Dr Fear with the triple post for emphasis!

Yes, I have a probe.  I'll start it first thing in the am.  Go maybe 8-10 hrs.  

No shit, triple post and he's right back up to 18 hours.

 

Dang just thought of something... where the hell is Champkind?  Haven't seen anything from him in a while.

Edited by SHOOTER12

No shit, triple post and he's right back up to 18 hours.
 
Dang just thought of something... where the hell is Champkind?  Haven't seen anything from him in a while.
Hmmm....bcfcd18cbf54337e65a02ee342cebe77.jpg
No shit, triple post and he's right back up to 18 hours.
 
Dang just thought of something... where the hell is Champkind?  Haven't seen anything from him in a while.

Laying low since he cost a lot of people a lot of money and is getting sued and other shit.

Laying low since he cost a lot of people a lot of money and is getting sued and other shit.
His investors are suing him?
His investors are suing him?

No. Companies he took loans out with and can’t pay back. Loans he didn’t disclose to his investors.

No. Companies he took loans out with and can’t pay back. Loans he didn’t disclose to his investors.
Gotcha. Personal guarantees are a bitch.
8 hours ago, Ldogg53 said:


No. Companies he took loans out with and can’t pay back. Loans he didn’t disclose to his investors.

That guy made some bad business decisions?  I’m shocked.  Shocked I tell ya.

14 hours ago, Ldogg53 said:


Laying low since he cost a lot of people a lot of money and is getting sued and other shit.

tumblr_ml66t2LkAP1qgrjt5o2_500.gifv

Back to brisket - I managed to find Prime brisket at my Costco today at $2.79 / pound.  Based upon the dire predictions about the price and availability of beef, I feel like I won the lottery (small scratch off prize, but won the lottery nonetheless). 

24 minutes ago, Jerry Callo said:

Back to brisket - I managed to find Prime brisket at my Costco today at $2.79 / pound.  Based upon the dire predictions about the price and availability of beef, I feel like I won the lottery (small scratch off prize, but won the lottery nonetheless). 

Hope you bought out the entire store, and then lit briskets on fire with hundred dollar bills on your way out the door! :)

 

I've hit the stall at 160.  Been sitting at 160 for an hour.  Do I wrap it to get it over the hump or wait it out?  Want to be able to serve in about 4-4.5 hrs, so pulling in 3 to 3.5 hrs

Edited by Sbbruin

How long has it been on? You can alway kick the temp up to 275.

3 minutes ago, Dr Fear said:

How long has it been on? You can alway kick the temp up to 275.

been on about 5 hrs

OK, broke on through to the other side.  Unwrap to finish or keep wrapped?

Keep wrapped imo. You could unwrap for firmer bark, but not needed

You’d rather finish early and have more resting time than finish late

Can't get it past 190.  OK to pull and wrap?  Want to give it a resting period, but can't wait to get the last 5 degrees

Can't get it past 190.  OK to pull and wrap?  Want to give it a resting period, but can't wait to get the last 5 degrees
You probe for tenderness?
3 minutes ago, Dr Fear said:
5 minutes ago, Sbbruin said:
Can't get it past 190.  OK to pull and wrap?  Want to give it a resting period, but can't wait to get the last 5 degrees

You probe for tenderness?

Yep, seems pretty good.

Yep, seems pretty good.
In the flat too? Pull it if that is the case. Sounds a bit low though. I am still mad at myself for pulling the last one early, flat was not great.

Anyone have any ideas for sides? Doing a brisket tomorrow and I always do beans, potato salad, mac n cheese and/or collard greens. Still going to do beans and probably mac n cheese, just want to try something different. Or maybe a different spin on something

I almost never pull before 203* anymore

Anyone have any ideas for sides? Doing a brisket tomorrow and I always do beans, potato salad, mac n cheese and/or collard greens. Still going to do beans and probably mac n cheese, just want to try something different. Or maybe a different spin on something


Cream corn is our go-to
I almost never pull before 203* anymore
I've gotten of the opinion that way more people pull too early rather than late.
42 minutes ago, Dr Fear said:
50 minutes ago, Sbbruin said:
Yep, seems pretty good.

In the flat too? Pull it if that is the case. Sounds a bit low though. I am still mad at myself for pulling the last one early, flat was not great.

It’s only a 4.5 pounder, so not really sure if it’s all flat or all point, but pretty sure not both

1 hour ago, NateHitch said:

Anyone have any ideas for sides? Doing a brisket tomorrow and I always do beans, potato salad, mac n cheese and/or collard greens. Still going to do beans and probably mac n cheese, just want to try something different. Or maybe a different spin on something

Cornbread salad is a crowd pleaser and one that people don't have very often. 

Double the "dressing" part on just about any recipe you find. 

 

 

Edited by squib

In the flat too? Pull it if that is the case. Sounds a bit low though. I am still mad at myself for pulling the last one early, flat was not great.

Well, it was dry as fuck, despite pulling at 190. Taste was good, nice and tender, just not juicy. Ribs were good though, but I have those pretty wired. But I ate barbecue, so it was good. Fam liked it.2af6bc3cc3aaea7ce572166dc6424603.jpg

Well, it was dry as fuck, despite pulling at 190. Taste was good, nice and tender, just not juicy. Ribs were good though, but I have those pretty wired. But I ate barbecue, so it was good. Fam liked it.2af6bc3cc3aaea7ce572166dc6424603.jpg
I think you pulled it too early.
5 minutes ago, Dr Fear said:
8 minutes ago, Sbbruin said:

Well, it was dry as fuck, despite pulling at 190. Taste was good, nice and tender, just not juicy. Ribs were good though, but I have those pretty wired. But I ate barbecue, so it was good. Fam liked it.2af6bc3cc3aaea7ce572166dc6424603.jpg

I think you pulled it too early.

Wouldn’t that run counter to being dry?  Seems like dryness means I left it on too long

Wouldn’t that run counter to being dry?  Seems like dryness means I left it on too long
That is the weird part, and probably makes it so tough to cook. Narrow window to get it right.
14 minutes ago, Dr Fear said:
30 minutes ago, Sbbruin said:
Wouldn’t that run counter to being dry?  Seems like dryness means I left it on too long

That is the weird part, and probably makes it so tough to cook. Narrow window to get it right.

And why I don’t cook brisket much.  I have pork butt and ribs nailed.  But have never made a brisket I’m proud of.  I think it requires old school offset smoke .  Or a metal turkey pan with liquid smoke.  Maybe I should just stick with sushi. 


Well, it was dry as fuck, despite pulling at 190. Taste was good, nice and tender, just not juicy. Ribs were good though, but I have those pretty wired. But I ate barbecue, so it was good. Fam liked it.2af6bc3cc3aaea7ce572166dc6424603.jpg


Not every picture should be shared.

You pulled it too soon.

Water pan, wrap 4 hours in, let the damn thing finish cooking.

24 minutes ago, luke duke said:

 


Not every picture should be shared.

You pulled it too soon.

 

Agreed.  I shared so I can learn.  One thing I understand is my brisket game needs work.  I didn’t have time to let it cook longer.

I've gotten of the opinion that way more people pull too early rather than late.

That’s what she said.

 

 

And you pulled too soon. Listen to Lurch.

3 hours ago, Sbbruin said:

I didn’t have time to let it cook longer.

you can't rush them. my guess is you now know that

30 minutes ago, strangulation! said:

you can't rush them. my guess is you now know that

 

C94D54E8-BA5E-4D57-B42D-5E960B094D38.gif

And why I don’t cook brisket much.  I have pork butt and ribs nailed.  But have never made a brisket I’m proud of.  I think it requires old school offset smoke .  Or a metal turkey pan with liquid smoke.  Maybe I should just stick with sushi. 
What are you cooking on?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.