December 13Dec 13 Author It was clear.as.fucking.day. i dont have a dog in the fight. But i am a rabid cfb fan. I cant believe that call. Cannot.believe.it.
December 14Dec 14 But, was it worse than this call? Line Judge nearest the play rules this a TD, but the crew takes it off the board after talking it over. No instant replay review in TXHSFB. Helluva way to end Southlake Carroll's season.
December 14Dec 14 Popular Post 4 minutes ago, DFW Horn said: But, was it worse than this call? Line Judge nearest the play rules this a TD, but the crew takes it off the board after talking it over. No instant replay review in TXHSFB. Helluva way to end Southlake Carroll's season. this was a correct call, so yes, the other call was the worse of the two calls.
December 14Dec 14 Author 29 minutes ago, DFW Horn said: But, was it worse than this call? Line Judge nearest the play rules this a TD, but the crew takes it off the board after talking it over. No instant replay review in TXHSFB. Helluva way to end Southlake Carroll's season. Yes
December 14Dec 14 9 hours ago, DFW Horn said: But, was it worse than this call? Line Judge nearest the play rules this a TD, but the crew takes it off the board after talking it over. No instant replay review in TXHSFB. Helluva way to end Southlake Carroll's season. pretty fucked up that the referee with the U comes from behind the play and argues with the actual official standing on the pylon with the best view that signaled TD
December 14Dec 14 And don't foget about Westlake. We were robbed over and over all saeson. It's because we spoke out against the system and are now being censored. Aggie, too.
December 14Dec 14 15 hours ago, Darth Tron said: I'm no rules expert, but didn't we learn last year (from the Arch TD against aggy) that the goal line extends into infinity and the ball doesn't have to cross inside the pylon? He isn't actually out of bounds until his elbow hits past the broad white border. At that point the ball is well over the theoretical goal line.
December 14Dec 14 Author 5 minutes ago, Horndog said: I'm no rules expert, but didn't we learn last year (from the Arch TD against aggy) that the goal line extends into infinity and the ball doesn't have to cross inside the pylon? He isn't actually out of bounds until his elbow hits past the broad white border. At that point the ball is well over the theoretical goal line. Im not sure this is correct but I may be wrong
December 14Dec 14 This was the worst year of football officiating I've ever seen. There were so many games where the outcome was decided by the zebras. It was either blatant corruption or Kevin Mar level incompetence throughout the sport.
December 14Dec 14 17 minutes ago, Horndog said: I'm no rules expert, but didn't we learn last year (from the Arch TD against aggy) that the goal line extends into infinity and the ball doesn't have to cross inside the pylon? He isn't actually out of bounds until his elbow hits past the broad white border. At that point the ball is well over the theoretical goal line. Only when a body part hits the pylon.
December 14Dec 14 1 minute ago, Dark Horse said: Only when a body part hits the pylon. I think this is correct. A body part had to hit in the end zone or the pylon. In this video the runner reaches for the pylon but never hits it.
December 14Dec 14 I think our call against Vandy was worse because you actually had good video evidence that wasn’t taken from 10,000 ft that shows the ball was a half yard short.
December 14Dec 14 12 hours ago, DFW Horn said: But, was it worse than this call? Line Judge nearest the play rules this a TD, but the crew takes it off the board after talking it over. No instant replay review in TXHSFB. Helluva way to end Southlake Carroll's season. Are you nominating this for best overturned call? He was short and the refs got a huge season defining call correct in the end.
December 14Dec 14 20 hours ago, MontereyMX said: worse than Vandy call! Not even close. You could clearly see the ball carrier and the ball the entire way, with multiple angles and cameras showing he didn't make it. Plus the Vandy call, was in conjunction with other manufactured calls/no-calls to get them points. That the SEC never said shit about it, unlike the Auburn ref incident.
December 14Dec 14 Author I can buy the vandy call because of the laces. However it should have been short on the field call the pvamu call was just straight up wrong. In no world should that have been good. It was like the michigan/SC call before the Clowney hit/ball dont lie
December 14Dec 14 3 hours ago, Horndog said: I'm no rules expert, but didn't we learn last year (from the Arch TD against aggy) that the goal line extends into infinity and the ball doesn't have to cross inside the pylon? He isn't actually out of bounds until his elbow hits past the broad white border. At that point the ball is well over the theoretical goal line. He has to touch the pylon to get the extension. He never touched the pylon.
December 14Dec 14 Author 1 hour ago, The_Great_Hornsby said: He has to touch the pylon to get the extension. He never touched the pylon. This
December 14Dec 14 The aggy hold/tackle against ND was up there. The officials clearly decided that no calls would be made against aggy on that play since it was impossible to not see the hold.
December 14Dec 14 You are ALL wrong. The worst call of the season was not giving the SCST and PVAMU dance teams any TV time.
December 14Dec 14 4 hours ago, Firemans4Horn said: Are you nominating this for best overturned call? He was short and the refs got a huge season defining call correct in the end. Bad call by the line judge to go up with a TD signal. Photos above and video POV from the EZ proved that overturning the L was the correct call.
December 14Dec 14 7 hours ago, MontereyMX said: pretty fucked up that the referee with the U comes from behind the play and argues with the actual official standing on the pylon with the best view that signaled TD Agreed, but photos from other angles proved it was correct to overrule the flank official on that play. Tough call for the L. I'm not surprised Coach Dodge went ballistic.
December 14Dec 14 4 hours ago, Pato del Muerto said: I think dfwhorn needs to change his name to slchorn Lol...my kid doesn't even go to SLC Now that I've seen additional photos and video from the EZ, I see the officials made the correct call.
December 14Dec 14 2 hours ago, GreenspointTexas said: I can buy the vandy call because of the laces. However it should have been short on the field call His knee is down short of the pylon. The pylon camera view actually makes it look closer since some moron aligned it with the rear edge of the goal line instead of the leading edge. He was well short of breaking the vertical plane.
December 15Dec 15 9 hours ago, GreenspointTexas said: I can buy the vandy call because of the laces. Well, then you're an idiot.
December 15Dec 15 SLC's quarterback, Renda, actually fumbled the ball on the play. It never broke the plane.
December 15Dec 15 21 hours ago, Billy Pilgrim said: I think our call against Vandy was worse because you actually had good video evidence that wasn’t taken from 10,000 ft that shows the ball was a half yard short. Yeah, this one is even farther from being a touchdown, and it's pretty clear, but that Vandy bullshit was at a perfect angle, lined up on the goal line, from just a few feet away. The only way you give Vandy that conversion is if you just want to. Edited December 15Dec 15 by TexArcher
December 15Dec 15 On 12/14/2025 at 6:28 AM, MontereyMX said: pretty fucked up that the referee with the U comes from behind the play and argues with the actual official standing on the pylon with the best view that signaled TD Well the guy with the “best view” was blind or cheating. They got the call right
December 15Dec 15 21 minutes ago, Sawbonz said: Well the guy with the “best view” was blind or cheating. They got the call right call was correct, the #U stripes actions, not so much
December 15Dec 15 Tarleton State getting robbed of their game winning touchdown is right up there. WR's left foot was clearly down in the end zone before his right foot came down out of bounds.
December 16Dec 16 9 hours ago, baboso said: Tarleton State getting robbed of their game winning touchdown is right up there. WR's left foot was clearly down in the end zone before his right foot came down out of bounds. NO! his left foot was clearly an inch off the turf before his right foot came down out of bounds and he knocked the bald phone cameraman into next week.
December 16Dec 16 Prairie View call is the worst call on a play. Kirby getting out of being charged a timeout was the most dumbass nonsense outside of action on the field.
December 16Dec 16 14 hours ago, MontereyMX said: call was correct, the #U stripes actions, not so much How do you figure the side judge has the best view when he couldn’t see the ball?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.