Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

43 minutes ago, Brisketexan said:

I know, I've said it before, and maybe folks don't agree....but it makes me sad when folks kill a big, OLD fish like that.  I catch and keep plenty of fish for eating, but I also do a whole lot of catch and release, and I think alligator gar are some of the coolest fish that we have in the state. They're prehistoric beasts.  And killing an old one like that just seems pointless.

I mean, I'm sure it was a cool and exhilarating experience, but I just wish they could weigh and measure the fish, and slip her back into the lake.

I'm admittedly torn.  First off, I would shit my britches if I was face to face with that fish while spearfishing.  Second, I'm not sure I could do it.  I love hunting and fishing, and I think that if it's not against the law, then more power to them.  But, like you, I don't think I could or would personally take something like that purely for sport.  

  • Replies 940
  • Views 72.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • 14 snappers, 10 dorado, 3 white marlin. Left from Surfside on Tuesday night and got back Thursday afternoon.   Have some video of the marlin. Need to upload those.      

  • Errestaurants
    Errestaurants

    Cedar Creek fish fry Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

  • Pescado_Rojo
    Pescado_Rojo

Side topic... How long until TPWD implements tags for oversized trout?

Florida has slots for not only Redfish, but also Black Drum and Specks among others.  15"-20" slot for trout and 14"-24" for black drum.  All others are catch and release.  I had a tough decision last year when my son hauled in a 26" Speck.  We ended up keeping her, but I regretted it as soon as she was in the box.  Should have thrown her back.  Do you think TPWD will try to slot Specks and Black Drum anytime soon?  

1 hour ago, Brisketexan said:

I know, I've said it before, and maybe folks don't agree....but it makes me sad when folks kill a big, OLD fish like that.  I catch and keep plenty of fish for eating, but I also do a whole lot of catch and release, and I think alligator gar are some of the coolest fish that we have in the state. They're prehistoric beasts.  And killing an old one like that just seems pointless.

I mean, I'm sure it was a cool and exhilarating experience, but I just wish they could weigh and measure the fish, and slip her back into the lake.

Yep.  I release all the big fish I catch.  If I'm going to eat some, I keep the mid size fish.  But I was thinking the same  thing as I looked at those 2 monsters hanging there.

Quote

“That’s the last alligator gar I’ll ever kill personally. I have an uber respect for an animal that long-lived, and they’re becoming a rarity here in Texas.”

He says as he fails to connect the dots.

Oh, wells.

Might be a spear gun record but it's far off the world record. I know a guy wh9 got one with a bow that was 292 lbs and just over 8 ft.

On 8/26/2018 at 12:31 PM, Lurch said:

I’ve been wanting to do this, but glad someone else took the risk first
 

 

Is he saying "walleye?" Do what, now? I don't know from salties, but I never heard that one before.

I know, I've said it before, and maybe folks don't agree....but it makes me sad when folks kill a big, OLD fish like that.  I catch and keep plenty of fish for eating, but I also do a whole lot of catch and release, and I think alligator gar are some of the coolest fish that we have in the state. They're prehistoric beasts.  And killing an old one like that just seems pointless.

I mean, I'm sure it was a cool and exhilarating experience, but I just wish they could weigh and measure the fish, and slip her back into the lake.

Yeah that guy that speared the gar is an asshole.

 

Part of the reason I got a big live well in my new boat is so I could keep a few smallish legal trout and then release them unharmed if I only caught 1 or 2 which to me isn't enough to break out the filet knife. I'll keep a single red because a 18 (legal in LA) or 20 inch fish is enough for 2 people.

 

1 hour ago, Spaulding Smails said:

Side topic... How long until TPWD implements tags for oversized trout?

Florida has slots for not only Redfish, but also Black Drum and Specks among others.  15"-20" slot for trout and 14"-24" for black drum.  All others are catch and release.  I had a tough decision last year when my son hauled in a 26" Speck.  We ended up keeping her, but I regretted it as soon as she was in the box.  Should have thrown her back.  Do you think TPWD will try to slot Specks and Black Drum anytime soon?  

I don't think think TPWD will change the slot for trout anytime soon.   Right now TPWD is grappling over whether to institute the 5-fish limit on the upper coast (FM 457 in Sargent to Sabine Lake).  If TPWD were to do anything with respect to bigger specks it would be to implement a tag system similar to reds for fish over 25".  But I don't even think that will happen anytime soon.

Edited by Dry Elbows

re the gar, why, just why?  just because it's legal and you can doesn't mean that you should.  kinda like shooting a giraffe, elephant, lion, etc.  why?

i'm of the mind that if you're going to kill it, it better because your life was threatened or you're gonna eat it.  killing those gars are pointless.  idiots.

4 hours ago, Brisketexan said:

I know, I've said it before, and maybe folks don't agree....but it makes me sad when folks kill a big, OLD fish like that.  I catch and keep plenty of fish for eating, but I also do a whole lot of catch and release, and I think alligator gar are some of the coolest fish that we have in the state. They're prehistoric beasts.  And killing an old one like that just seems pointless.

I mean, I'm sure it was a cool and exhilarating experience, but I just wish they could weigh and measure the fish, and slip her back into the lake.

Put me in the don’t get it camp. His comment in the last part of the story make it worse in my opinion. I’m primarily catch and release and will just keep what we want to eat that day.

Hard to catch and release with a spear gun.

Hard to catch and release with a spear gun.
And he knew that before he went in the water. He doesn't give a shit about catch and release.
12 hours ago, huge said:

Hard to catch and release with a spear gun.

I get the humor but it's easier to pick the fish you want to take and only those fish with a spear.  

I ate all the fish I speared. 

1 hour ago, huge said:

I ate all the fish I speared. 

Not me. Not all of them. 

29 minutes ago, Lat22 said:

Not me. Not all of them. 

Ummmm....we still talkin' 'bout fish?

On 8/27/2018 at 10:40 AM, huge said:

Decarb boat I went out on recently had a good weekend.

4 sails

2 whites

1 blue

15 dorado

That’s a nice haul. We fished our last tournament of the year Saturday. TWAT Tournament. Won 2nd place overall and first place blue marlin. Check got a bonus for a wahoo pot too and it ended up being for almost as much as when we won it 3 years ago. Good end to,the season.

So it’s another beautiful evening on Jax Beach, but I’m not real happy with my bait. Just some juvenile whiting and fiddler crabs and not getting any bites. We can see 5 gulls slamming the water north of us and they slowly get closer over 10-15 minutes. Suddenly I can see the water they’re hitting and it looks like it’s boiling! I sprint out with my cast net and wait for the pod to get closer. It’s not the mullet I’m used to seeing, but something silver and pretty good size. Finally it reaches me and I toss the 6’ net near the edge, as far as I could throw with a decent pancake. The water EXPLODES and I drag the net to shore with 20-30 menhaden! I had only ever caught 1 before and it was sickly. These fish were solid. Guys on both sides of me rush over with their nets and do the same. On of them tells me they’re menhaden (calls them porgy) and tells me to run a hook through mouth and nose then toss it out and “hang on”.

I bait up both polls, keep a few more and return the rest. I can see the pod continuing south. Not 5 mins after hitting the water one of the polls bends 90* and the drag starts screaming... fish on! Damn thing nearly spools me but I got him under control and start a LONG battle to bring him in. Like that last big one that got away a few weeks ago, this one goes north, then out, then south on me. I work him in near the breakers but can’t seem to get him any closer for the longest time. There’s a large crowd around me and I don’t want to rush this one like last time and lose him, so I loosen the drag and let him run a few times. Finally I can tell he’s out of gas and wait for a big wave to push him in. Landed him! 3-4’ black tip. Not sure how, but had him hooked in the neck below his mouth. I couldn’t get the hook out of that tough skin so I had to release the hook and leave it in.

I pull him by the tail back in the water and hold him towards the surf to help him breathe. He’s not pulling very hard so I keep holding on but a big wave crashed into us and I lose grip. He rolls around a bit and I can tell he’s not ready, so I’ve got to grab his tail again... yikes! Finally I get him set again and after several minutes he starts pulling away and makes a pretty strong run out.

What a blast! I was absolutely EXHAUSTED by the time he took off. Catch of my life and it’s not even close

Random guy just sent me pics
7559bebad042886c3bf55b66194ff973.jpg

52b7fe22345aec040331c6f770a0b3ae.jpg

f14148d6cb173deb3c0e35dab7d7229e.jpg

Probably was the guy in the Speedo that sent them ....

I was so focused on releasing him ASAP that I didn’t grab my phone to take pics. Someone in the crowd said they would so I didn’t think any more of it. I didn’t realize they were using a phone from 2004.

 

Speedo dude was German and despite the fact that I didn’t speak German and he didn’t speak English, he was insistent that we carry on a lengthy conversation afterwards. It’s possible I’m now committed to marrying his daughter or he gave me the recipe for German deviled eggs.

 

Headed out this weekend to do some bluefin fishing of socal. Got half way to the grounds and lost the port side main. limped back home. Womp womp.

Nothing super big this summer. No doubt, all the trophy trout are saving themselves for a run at my flies and lures this fall.

However, a buddy and I hit one of my favorite spots that hasn't been worth fishing for nearly half a year and got into some decent trout, including my two biggest Bonnies (~18 inches), one super colorful rainbow (~19 inches), and one chubby girl.

IMG_7790.jpg

IMG_7795.jpg

IMG_7796.jpg

IMG_7811.jpg

029_B6_C9_E047_B0000_DB200003_attachment

Waded Saturday in POC. Was strange day. Started slow but managed to scratch a limit of trout and then went hunting reds and flounder. Found some nice ones. I finally picked up a flounder on a Chicken Boy lemon pepper, but he was only 13 inches. That would have completed my slam.

My biggest red was 29 1/2. Angle of the pic makes it look 40 of course. It had a shaker weight and hook still in it from breaking off somebody earlier in the weekend.

My old man went out on his own and found five solid trout. That’s a size 12 shoe in the pic.

5da6f6e2b4995eb7c0fbcd47a569cb8b.png


dab518047a900bb2e056770f0c0aa7a3.jpg


e8153669b610b0910ab6f35b879c8dd0.png

58e75f8276c814165d96a1502dec16d6.png

Thought we were wasting our time doing some nearshore bay boat trolling here in the Florida Panhandle. Not so. Bagged two of these girls.

Earlier we caught a couple good reds at sunrise. Also waded through some hoss smacks while grouper trolling. f298a5b42d8719ad941dd46f9c524245.jpg

Natty...that shows commitment.

They see me trolling. . .they hating. . . Tryna catch me riding dirty.

Went fly fishing for the first time this past weekend and hooked into a bunch of rainbows. One of the last I caught had a weird yellow spot underneath and my guide said hes never anything like that before

20eb0bab680abbc0a18b2eeb1a94891a.jpg

That is strange.  I wonder if it indicates some sort of disease or is just a weird marking. 

Did you keep him?   I have not kept a freshwater trout in years, but I would have been very tempted to take that one out of the population.  

I catch 'em with similar splotches on their bellies often enough, but have never seen one that big. I wonder if it's analogous to a birthmark.

maybe anecdotal but the 1 red i caught with one of those spots had a soft plastic lure inside it's stomach.  i ate that bitch and haven't had a yellow spot show up on my belly.  

Catching these all day long

 

20180916_120042.jpg
 

Flying out in a couple hours to Sanibel, we’ll see how it goes after their crappy summer. Rumor is reds and snook are moving again, so hopefully it will be productive.

dbd861c2cceaf22903e0fc3b8f339474.jpg

Any idea what these are? Caught a school of them in my cast net. Juvenile menhaden?

Trolling the cedar plug. We shall see.
ad50086e4785c36a6e90a2651ebfcf4a.jpg

No go.  Trolled the rapala this am which usually pays off on calicos but not today.

I will be in the hill country this weekend and I plan to do some bass fishing in some small ponds.  I will be fishing from the bank.  Any recommendations on lures?

Chartreuse spinner baits. Green/brown/reddish colored platics (worms, jigs, brush hogs, lizards, etc...).
Or get some minners

Small spinners, wacky worming, topwaters like tiny torpedos, short lipped crank baits, frogs.

A two bladed H&H spinner never fails in a stock pond.  I always have 3 or 4 different colored ones in my spinner box at all times.  If they aren't biting anything else I can usually throw those and figure out what color they like that day.  Black/White and Chartreuse seem to work the most but Red/White has been the only thing that will get a bite some days too.

 

I went fly fishing last week around Crested Butte and the water was depressingly low.  We picked up a few here and there but nothing like it has been in previous years, especially in the small creeks up in the mountains where it's usually 3 wt/Brookie heaven.

I’ve been fishing w live finger mullets a lot recently. I’ve been hooking them under mouth and up through between the eyes. I’ve pulled in dozens of them to find only the head left. Frustrated, I usually hook the next few through the back but then never get hits.
Anyone have experience with this?

16 hours ago, Lurch said:

I’ve been fishing w live finger mullets a lot recently. I’ve been hooking them under mouth and up through between the eyes. I’ve pulled in dozens of them to find only the head left. Frustrated, I usually hook the next few through the back but then never get hits.
Anyone have experience with this?

Have you tried dorsal hooking?  Short of that, double hooking although your baits may not be large enough for that.

Have you tried dorsal hooking?  Short of that, double hooking although your baits may not be large enough for that.


Ah. I was doing it behind the dorsal fin. I’ll try in front next
14 minutes ago, Hugh G. Rection said:

Have you tried dorsal hooking?  Short of that, double hooking although your baits may not be large enough for that.

are we still talking about fishing?

Edited by CoTex

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.