Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Surly Horns

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Just now, Huckleberry said:

It was underthrown and fluttering but can be forgiven because of the back foot slip and the receiver having his guy beaten easily. But let's not get crazy and call it a great throw. It dropped right into Dixon's hands because Dixon adjusted well, not because it was thrown perfectly. 

Fair, it was not perfect, but it wasn't extremely underthrown or overthrown either. It was thrown well enough that Dixon was able to make a play on the ball, with a guy coming at Casey. I'm not real sure why we are even complaining or expecting perfection from a guy that had 4 completions this year prior to this game. 

  • Replies 2.6k
  • Views 256.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • He's just reversing his Dad's college career, who started out as a Sooner and ended it wearing orange.      

  • Ignatius
    Ignatius

    Shit man, I used to study film 12 hours a day pretty much every day. Then one time my wife walked in and we had to go to fucking marriage counseling…

  • FORTY NINE TO ZERO
    FORTY NINE TO ZERO

    Casey would have beat arky.  I will believe that until the day I die. 

Posted Images

  • Popular Post

How great for Thompson if he can come into Spring and win the job in a fair competition - and still have three years of eligibility left.  3 years on the bench learning, maturing, and getting stronger.  Come in as a 21 year old first time starter and still have plenty of time to leave your mark on the program. 

Fair, it was not perfect, but it wasn't extremely underthrown or overthrown either. It was thrown well enough that Dixon was able to make a play on the ball, with a guy coming at Casey. I'm not real sure why we are even complaining or expecting perfection from a guy that had 4 completions this year prior to this game. 
Exactly. It was also a high IQ throw. He found the open guy, saw his margin of error, and threw well within that margin. Dixon had to adjust, but the adjustment was slight, and he still caught the ball in stride.
  • Popular Post
27 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

50 yards through the air with velocity, just spectacular. 

His best throw of the night was the juke of the DE and the lofted pass over 2 defenders to Brewer on 3rd and long. I was impressed with Casey in this game, but I am not going to pencil in 10 wins next season just yet. 

How great for Thompson if he can come into Spring and win the job in a fair competition - and still have three years of eligibility left.  3 years on the bench learning, maturing, and getting stronger.  Come in as a 21 year old first time starter and still have plenty of time to leave your mark on the program. 
And let's not forget how much Bijan being in the backfield will open things up in the passing game. Thompson is going to see a lot of one-on-one situations when defenses realize they need to load the box to have any hope of stopping Bijan.
10 minutes ago, Vertigo said:

His best throw of the night was the juke of the DE and the lofted pass over 2 defenders to Brewer on 3rd and long. I was impressed with Casey in this game, but I am not going to pencil in 10 wins next season just yet. 

How can you with the current head coach?

  • Popular Post
10 hours ago, Spider2YBanana said:

No doubt. I always forget his dad was ou's QB. How was his dad as a thrower?

He could deal it back in the day.

7 minutes ago, Vertigo said:

His best throw of the night was the juke of the DE and the lofted pass over 2 defenders to Brewer on 3rd and long. I was impressed with Casey in this game, but I am not going to pencil in 10 wins next season just yet. 

The only criticism I have of Casey was his jittery footwork in the pocket. Maybe it was a bad cleat/turf combo or nerves. To his credit, he overcame it in spectacular fashion and I'm excited AF about his potential. How bad is the got damn Pac12 if that team beat UCLA and Stanford? 

35 minutes ago, taybo20 said:

Fair, it was not perfect, but it wasn't extremely underthrown or overthrown either. It was thrown well enough that Dixon was able to make a play on the ball, with a guy coming at Casey. I'm not real sure why we are even complaining or expecting perfection from a guy that had 4 completions this year prior to this game. 

Casey Thompson fucks, I'm sorry you misunderstood my other post in the game thread about his performance. 

45 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

The point is Sam can't make that same throw at all.

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

Quote

 

 

Seems like a great kid who flashed a ton of talent. Looked great slinging the ball deep, made mostly smart decisions, looked electric when he ran the ball.

All the potential in the world; I'm anxious to see how many more Alamo Bowls he can win under Tom Herman's mentorship.

Really happy for this kid.  Putting aside our program's fuckery, this guy has worked hard, waited patiently, and appears to be a very good QB.  Imagine how proud his folks must be for his coming out party.  

  • Popular Post
2 minutes ago, satyanash said:

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

 

Yeah, I think people are misremembering, or just flat fucking hate Sam.

Sam HAS made plenty of Big throws.  Deep and accurate throws.  He didn't do it much this season for a multitude of reasons, and maybe Casey is already better than he ever was at it.

But can't we stop this "Sam never has/couldn't make that throw" bullshit?  Ya'll just exposing yourselves.

20 minutes ago, Mikey4 said:

And let's not forget how much Bijan being in the backfield will open things up in the passing game. Thompson is going to see a lot of one-on-one situations when defenses realize they need to load the box to have any hope of stopping Bijan.

"Rachel Phelps Tom Herman will never allow that to happen."

spacer.png

43 minutes ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

How great for Thompson if he can come into Spring and win the job in a fair competition - and still have three years of eligibility left.  3 years on the bench learning, maturing, and getting stronger.  Come in as a 21 year old first time starter and still have plenty of time to leave your mark on the program. 

If Casey is good enough, he will play awesome football and get drafted before those 3 years are up. Because that's what athletes with a high ceiling do -- go to the draft, not stick around in college for 5 years.

4 minutes ago, satyanash said:

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

 

Lulz. Casey showed last night what a lot of us have been saying all season. Sam has been missing reads and not playing within the context of the offense. He’s still a good QB and the offensive struggled are not all his fault, but he has absolutely been missing open reads, struggled with accuracy and hung around in the pocket too long. He has  struggled a lot this year and he’s not a good fit for Yurcich’s offense, which relies on beating teams deep to open up the underneath stuff. 

1 minute ago, Burt Macklin said:

Lulz. Casey showed last night what a lot of us have been saying all season. Sam has been missing reads and not playing within the context of the offense. He’s still a good QB and the offensive struggled are not all his fault, but he has absolutely been missing open reads, struggled with accuracy and hung around in the pocket too long. He has  struggled a lot this year and he’s not a good fit for Yurcich’s offense, which relies on beating teams deep to open up the underneath stuff. 

The struggled is real.

11 minutes ago, satyanash said:

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

 

so time stamp which throw was 50 yards through the air on a dime for me....

1 minute ago, Burt Macklin said:

Lulz. Casey showed last night what a lot of us have been saying all season. Sam has been missing reads and not playing within the context of the offense. He’s still a good QB and the offensive struggled are not all his fault, but he has absolutely been missing open reads, struggled with accuracy and hung around in the pocket too long. He has  struggled a lot this year and he’s not a good fit for Yurcich’s offense, which relies on beating teams deep to open up the underneath stuff. 

Too many blows to head over his career.   Not all his fault as Tom’s philosophy on offense makes the QBS improvise more because of shit play calling.   It was the same with Tom’s mentor Greg Davis, but because Vince and Colt had better supporting members on the team along with being better athletes than Sam, they didn’t take the brutal punishment game after game that Sam did and they made Greg Davis offense look good with their talent alone. 

3 hours ago, BurntOrange&White said:

His injury issues go back to high school. 

I did not know that. Then yeah, he's going pro in something else. Good thing Herman wanted to make those injuries worse like a good coach does. 

3 minutes ago, Spider2YBanana said:

I did not know that. Then yeah, he's going pro in something else. Good thing Herman wanted to make those injuries worse like a good coach does. 

Not like Texas coaches has a history of using their QBs as battering rams to destroy their shoulders and heads.  Colt, David Ash and Sam can start a support group. 

1 hour ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

How great for Thompson if he can come into Spring and win the job in a fair competition - and still have three years of eligibility left.  3 years on the bench learning, maturing, and getting stronger.  Come in as a 21 year old first time starter and still have plenty of time to leave your mark on the program. 

 Thanks to Covid all of CFB can get the BYU elderly player experience 

Edited by perfectchaos007

I honestly feel like Sam should consider transitioning to TE in the NFL. We’ve seen it with Logan Thomas and Trey Burton recently. I actually think Sam would thrive in that role overtime 

29 minutes ago, satyanash said:

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

 

Don’t misrepresent the argument. Sam has thrown accurate long balls in his career.  A starter at a P5 program is supposed to be able to do that. 
 

The problem is he hasn’t completed many of them. Especially in this season. You could point them to his being banged up and that’s fair. But plain fact of the matter is, medium-long throws hitting receivers in stride this season is embarrassingly few and far in between. 
 

Just watch a season highlight of Lawrence, Trask, etc to see the difference. Hell, Fields has probably completed more bombs in 6 games than Ehlinger has. 

16 minutes ago, Js1 said:

Not like Texas coaches has a history of using their QBs as battering rams to destroy their shoulders and heads.  Colt, David Ash and Sam can start a support group. 

God this makes me sad. Not that Sam was going to make the NFL, but I worry he'll be walking like Earl Campbell by the time he hits 35

20 minutes ago, Spider2YBanana said:

God this makes me sad. Not that Sam was going to make the NFL, but I worry he'll be walking like Earl Campbell by the time he hits 35

A bit hyperbolic?

1 hour ago, immamac said:

Casey Thompson fucks, I'm sorry you misunderstood my other post in the game thread about his performance. 

I'm sorry it sounded like Herman's presser

Edited by taybo20

1 hour ago, perfectchaos007 said:

 Thanks to Covid all of CFB can get the BYU elderly player experience 

Do you think Taysom will come back for his senior season in 21?

3 hours ago, Jive Turkey said:

what if it turns out that VY is a poor man's Casey Thompson?

 

Sam overthrows this by 10 yards 

2 hours ago, Vertigo said:

His best throw of the night was the juke of the DE and the lofted pass over 2 defenders to Brewer on 3rd and long. I was impressed with Casey in this game, but I am not going to pencil in 10 wins next season just yet. 

That play earned Brewer 10 WR screens next year. 

1 hour ago, Spider2YBanana said:

God this makes me sad. Not that Sam was going to make the NFL, but I worry he'll be walking like Earl Campbell by the time he hits 35

Unless Sam is just a back-up in the NFL, I hope his football playing days are done. 

Stay healthy and enjoy the rest of your life -- You're A Great Longhorn Sam!!  🤘

8 minutes ago, Sgt Hulk said:

Sam overthrows this by 10 yards 

When he's healthy. When he's hurt, it's underthrown and jump ball. I love Sam and always will but he should move on.

17 minutes ago, ajax said:

I love Sam and always will but 

“I’m not an anti-Samite, but . . . .”

13 hours ago, Spider2YBanana said:

Sam ain't coming back. Why would he? Thompson has sat and learned what mistakes not to make. He's been patient, and he was hitting all the WR's on point. He made like 2 bad throws. Sam is a good kid, but he isn't beating out Thompson now. 

why do you believe it would be an open competition?

6 minutes ago, naija said:

why do you believe it would be an open competition?

I hope it's not. I liked what I saw from Thompson, even if it was just Colorado. He seemed so smooth and throws such a nice pass. I forgot all about the fact we had Eagles on the team when we didn't miss a beat with Moore. 

dont get too much wood about what u saw 

if herman is here next year casey will be coached to not run as much & to never keep the ball on a zone read 

4 hours ago, satyanash said:

He can and has. It's hilarious to see the usual group of Sam haters pretend that he's never thrown a good deep ball. But that's neither here nor there, Thompson's play last night was very encouraging.

 

The VERY FIRST THROW on that highlight reel is under thrown by four or five yards. Eagles has three full steps on the defender, and when the ball finally arrives, the defender actually has an outside shot at a PBU. That ball should be WAY farther in front of Eagles. It's a good read and good decision, but it's a hallmark average throw. 

5 hours ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

How great for Thompson if he can come into Spring and win the job in a fair competition - and still have three years of eligibility left.  3 years on the bench learning, maturing, and getting stronger.  Come in as a 21 year old first time starter and still have plenty of time to leave your mark on the program. 

Somehow Mike Leach had a guy like this ever other year. Some random dude who had been in the program for three years without starting and then averaged 300 yards a game.

This feels like the Aggie Rollercoaster of Hype. 

Without a doubt Casey had a great game...

...but he came in in the 2nd half with a lead against a crap team that was overmatched, that didn't scheme against him and with a RB that was averaging 18 yards a pop. 

Did he play great? Yes.  Did he show a lot of potential? Absolutely.  Should we be excited? Hell Yeah. 

 

Comparing him to VY (or even Spenser Rattler who has a full year under his belt and a QB Whisper for a Coach) seems a bit premature.  

Let's see if he can have that type of performance against TCU, ISU or OU.  We have to also remember that it's going to be the same coaching staff that doesn't seem to develop or use talent very well.

 

Until Herman is gone, I don't believe Casey or anyone else can  lead us to the promised land

We had a 7 point lead. It’s not like it was 35-0 after halftime and he came in. 

I have heard the “Sam was injured and it hurt his throwing” for 4 years now.  It reminds me of the “Aggy will only win 4 games if they are lucky this year” motto every offseason.

58 minutes ago, 0xdeadbeef said:

This feels like the Aggie Rollercoaster of Hype. 

Without a doubt Casey had a great game...

...but he came in in the 2nd half with a lead against a crap team that was overmatched, that didn't scheme against him and with a RB that was averaging 18 yards a pop. 

Did he play great? Yes.  Did he show a lot of potential? Absolutely.  Should we be excited? Hell Yeah. 

 

Comparing him to VY (or even Spenser Rattler who has a full year under his belt and a QB Whisper for a Coach) seems a bit premature.  

Let's see if he can have that type of performance against TCU, ISU or OU.  We have to also remember that it's going to be the same coaching staff that doesn't seem to develop or use talent very well.

 

Until Herman is gone, I don't believe Casey or anyone else can  lead us to the promised land

 

D509233D-2682-4D5A-94E9-02F4CB50A2ED.gif

6 hours ago, Js1 said:

Not like Texas coaches has a history of using their QBs as battering rams to destroy their shoulders and heads.  Colt, David Ash and Sam can start a support group. 

Are you seriously suggesting that Colt and Ash got used the same way Sam has?

Something that really has me thinking since last night is the first throw Thompson made coming out of half. 

It was a double post concept. I cannot remember us throwing that once all year. Not only was it the first play Casey threw, but they came back to it later for another td.

so either we have run that play and Sam never threw it, (Checkdown, run, etc as we can’t see what’s happening on the other side) or Sam can’t execute that throw/read so it was never brought to the game plan.

it just seems weird that your first pass play would be something that the starter never ran/executed.

 

Something that really has me thinking since last night is the first throw Thompson made coming out of half. 
It was a double post concept. I cannot remember us throwing that once all year. Not only was it the first play Casey threw, but they came back to it later for another td.
so either we have run that play and Sam never threw it, (Checkdown, run, etc as we can’t see what’s happening on the other side) or Sam can’t execute that throw/read so it was never brought to the game plan.
it just seems weird that your first pass play would be something that the starter never ran/executed.
 

I might get vilified by saying this, but this was the same damn thing I saw as an Eagles fan this season. Last night was like deja vu. Hurts comes in and it was like what? We have that play in the playbook? Same damn thing with Casey.
7 hours ago, Js1 said:

Not like Texas coaches has a history of using their QBs as battering rams to destroy their shoulders and heads.  Colt, David Ash and Sam can start a support group. 

Speaking of....what’s DA doing now?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.